0
votes

A History of NFL Draft 1st Picks

posted March 7, 2008 - 11:20am
A History of NFL Draft 1st Picks

I came across a very interesting and well written article today about the last 25 first picks in the NFL Draft and it got me to do some research. It seems that for every Peyton Manning and John Elway there is always a Tim Couch. Quarterbacks are the most chosen position for the first pick and sometimes, like Elway and Manning, they turn out really well but a majority of the time they turn out to be pretty mediocre. That mediocre group of first pick QBs would include Vinny Testaverde, Drew Bledsoe, Jeff George, Michael Vick and David Carr. None of these QBs can be labeled complete busts but none of them won a Super Bowl either.

The other skill positions aren't much better than the QB. Two RBs were selected in the last 25 years Bo Jackson and Ki-Jana Carter. While Ki-Jana Carter is the definition of a bust, Bo Jackson had some moments but was hampered by injuries. There were also two WRs take in the last 25 years, Keyshawn Johnson and Irving Fryar. Keyshawn was pretty good but Fryar was one of the best receivers of the 80s.

On the Defensive side of the ball, it is not a sure thing either. The best of the bunch has to be Bruce Smith who might be the best DE to ever play the game. But there is a list of forgettables like Aundray Bruce and Steve Emtman.

What I think is the safest place to go with an overall first pick is the Offensive Line. Only one offensive lineman was selected first overall in the last 25 years and that was Orlando Pace who is a sure bet Hall of Famer. Now there were other OL selected early in the draft that had great success. Tony Boselli was second overall in 1995, Richmond Webb was selected ninth in 1990, Jonathan Ogden was selected fourth in 1996 and Willie Roaf was selected eight in 1993. So my suggestion to the Miami Dolphins is to take Jake Long from Michigan. Don't go for the mediocre QB that Matt Ryan will become.


Tags:

Comments

Absolutely

What I wrote about Vick was my opinion. I still believe Vick was overrated. Others mileage may vary. ATTITUDE IS EVERYTHING

Okay, I just looked up the definition of marquis and marquee

Of course I meant to write "marquee" instead of "marquis." However, I want to add that what you have just written is merely your opinion. None of our opinions can be substituted for fact. Thanks for your correction... Join Xomba

Michael Vick

If Michael Vick were drafted as a running back, I would probably consider him a good player. But, as a quarterback, he was still a long ways from being a good player. While he had decent arm-strength, he was not terribly accurate and would tuck tail and run more often than he would stay in the pocket to take a hit in order to complete a pass. I will agree that he was a marquee player, but that stemmed mostly from people wanting to see him run for yards and scores than it did for wanting to seem him settle down in the pocket and go through his reads. One unfortunate consequence (of many) of the dogfighting scandal is that Vick was just starting to blossom as a bona fide quarterback and could have been a year or two from being a complete player. Now, by the time he is released, even if he get reinstated by the NFL, he will have lost all progress from learning the position and his age will take him past the prime for those types of mobile quarterbacks. ATTITUDE IS EVERYTHING

Michael Vick does not belong in a 'mediocre' category

Aside from the despicable things he did, and I might add he is serving time for what he did, Michael Vick was a world class player. Just because a player does not make it to the Superbowl does not take away from their being a marquis player. Football is a team sport. Although I disagree with some points in your article I like your style of writing. Good Job! Join Xomba

Sorry to disagree

Sorry man, the offensive line is the hardest position in football to learn. 99% of the rookie linemen out there have absolutely no chance of starting for at least 3 years maybe five. That is how much difference there is between the pros and college. If you remember Orlando Pace did horrible his first year which many people considered good for a rookie. So if you draft an O-lineman either you pay him big money to sit and learn or you risk your quarterback and running backs becoming comatosed. Either way he can be a bust - go ask the Packers who drafted Tony Mandrich(?). Ask the Bucs about Keyshawn Walker. It is better to go free agency and look for a vet or trade for one.

Visit my homepage here

Follow me on Twitter here

What's even worse is that those mistakes are expensive

What's even worse then the veritable crapshoot with the #1 picks is the amount of money they demand of the teams who draft them, knowing how desperate at team bad enough to have the #1 pick is going to be. Last year, LSU's Jamarcus Russel didn't sign anything and missed the mini-camps and training camp just so he could "get paid" by the Oakland Raiders. Despite Russel's me-first attitude, the Raiders still paid him an exorbitant amount of money for an untried and untested quarterback. If Russel busts, as you've shown many #1 picks to do, the Raiders are out a ton of money. (I'm not a fan of the Raiders or their fans, so I'm only using this as an example.) If you look at the salary averages of the top ten picks in the first round of any draft since the salary cap went into effect in 1992, you will see that it's almost a detriment to a team to have a high draft pick unless they have a burning need for a particular player to complete the team and have lots of room under the salary cap. What I would like to see become a rule in the NFL (not that the NFL player's association would agree) is a mandatory cap on the first and second year salaries of draft picks and undrafted free agents. If the salary topped out at--say--$200,000, there wouldn't be a bidding war for untried yet greedy talent and the players would actually have to focus on making the transition from good college player to great pro player before there is a salary offered commensurate with their abilities. ATTITUDE IS EVERYTHING

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member