Are We Being "Dumbed Down" Deliberately?


Are We Being "Dumbed Down" Deliberately?

5
points

I'm not one who is prone to taking very much stock in conspiracy theories. Truth is a very hard thing for the average person to uncover, and I don't generally expend a great amount of mental energy embracing theories that can't be proven. But there is one notion I've been entertaining as of late: Is the dumbing down of Americans deliberate?

I was watching a bit of George Carlin on YouTube some months ago -- a brilliant spot -- where he basically asserted that the true owners of the US (the corporate elite, bankers, etc) don't want a citizenry capable of "critical thought". They want stupid citizens who just follow along and don't question what they're told.

There is no doubt that our educational system is in serious crisis. With the abysmal failure of No Child Left Behind, the problem continues to get worse. It's a simplistic approach to a complex issue. By simply setting a standard schools are required to meet -- without giving them the resources needed to accomplish this goal, not taking into account the inequalities of our educational facilities -- you can be assured that the standard will get continually lowered, and the level of education for all plummets. It was doomed to failure from the start.

When George W. Bush leaves office next year, his greatest legacy is likely to be the effective use of fear propaganda and simple minded rhetoric to sell a dangerous agenda. That it worked well enough to get him elected to a second term is an embarrassment this country will not shake off for a long time to come. Patriotism has been equated with blind obedience. If the intelligence of the average American were higher, could this have been possible? Not likely.

The media, of course, figures into this scenario as well. They bombard us daily with fluff news pieces guaranteed to slowly erode your brain cells, and keep you blissfully pacified.

So it's understandable how one might be compelled to believe this "dumbing down" process is no accident. We'd better start nurturing "critical thought" before we, as a nation, lose the capacity entirely.






Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
lisadee's picture
Submitted by lisadee on Sun, 2008-05-18 18:46.

i agree that our society is in the process of dumbing down the masses. however, i disagree that a simple approach (such as no child left behind) is wrong. complex solutions do nothing more than line pocketbooks of those who come up with them. education is not complicated. remove the social engineering classes. return to the basics...reading, writing, arithmatic. eliminate the passing forward so that "self-esteem" is not harmed and hold back those kids who do not understand the material. return responsibility to the parents instead of the state. do those things and any perceived inequities among schools systems will no longer exist.



kjhack's picture
Submitted by kjhack on Sun, 2008-05-18 19:23.

There's no reason a solution to a problem needs to be complex. But in the case of NCLB, it was just a concept that wasn't workable. For one thing, you can't hold all students to the same standard simply because all students aren't the same.

I do think you are right about parents taking a larger role in the education of their children -- and a need to return to the "basics".

kjhack's Xombytes


kjhack's Xomblurbs


Join Zomba



Free Cracker 4 Jack's picture
Submitted by Free Cracker 4 Jack on Mon, 2008-05-19 12:14.

I loved your article. +1

FreeCracker4Jack
Would you like to earn money writing similar articles?
Click the link below. It's easy and it's Free!
CLICK ME!



kjhack's picture
Submitted by kjhack on Mon, 2008-05-19 20:58.

I'm glad you enjoyed my article. :)

Click here to read my stuff. It's really good stuff, I swear!


Click here to become a member of Xomba.



bigpink's picture
Submitted by bigpink on Mon, 2008-05-19 12:27.

The dumbing down of our people is part the government's fault, part technology's fault, and part the people's fault.

(technology includes the media)

The government uses techniques to scare our people, technology is used to open us up to conspiracies and scripted-truths, many created by the government, and our people follow blindly, as, if they were following the pied-piper.

But, I want to bring my focus of comment back to education. I do agree with the thoughts about focusing on reading, writing, and math. As, an example of the immediate need to return to these basics, I ask everyone this question:

How many people have you come in contact with who do not know how to count change-back, from a purchase?
Today, it is common to rely upon a machine to tell you how much change you get back. (technology).

I read papers written by university students, and even with spell-checkers, their spelling is absolutely terrible. Their writing has no-flow to it. It's choppy, at, best.

I student-taught kindergarten for two-years (best job I ever had!), and I worked under Mr. Scott McBeth, here in Portland (OR), and I was able to see him take those little people from not knowing too much, to being able to count to 1000, read from a book, speak a little Spanish, be able to multiply numbers up to the 12s, have a grasp of the science around us, and certainly, an understanding about their fellow classmates, Black, White, Asian, Hispanic, and Native American, and, upon their graduation to first grade, they graduated as one class, the classes of 2017, and 2018.

I remember asking Scott what his biggest fear was for those 28/26 kindergarten students, and here's what he told me, "my biggest fear is that they might end-up with a teacher who doesn't care."

It is unacceptable to continue to renew contracts of teachers who are not competent enough to give children the tools to travel in the 21st Century. Education can not be changed without everyone's input, whether you have children or not.

We must implement procedures to encourage our students, rather than the in-place policies, which discourage students. You want change? Get involved. Go to school board meetings, talk with your neighbors, write letters, bang on the doors of your representatives, make-a-big-sign, stand on a street corner, and bitch like hell!

Social engineering classes? Social engineering, to me, is the aim to better society through education about each other, about different cultures, about different people, about creating a world that works for everybody. Its hopeful result is that we become knowledgeable to the fact that we are not the only people on Earth. Social Engineering has rooted, within it, the aim of breaking down ethnocentric-based perceptions.

I am a proponent of social engineering. Barack Obama, and Hilary Clinton, would have never had a chance, in a million years, to run for President, had it not been for social engineering. Equal Rights would have never made it to the table had it not been for social engineering. Women would have never achieved the right-to-vote had it not been for social engineering.

And this past-year, Portland State University began White Studies, a look into racism, to go along with its Black Studies classes. This upcoming school year, 2008-09, the Portland Public Schools will initiate similar studies. These are what I term Social Engineering classes.

(Social Engineering has had its downsides too. Adolf Hitler used Social Engineering to spread his hate.)

And, with that said, I bring us back full-circle to parent(s). Back to the public. Back to each of us, as individuals. It is important to embrace social engineering in order to continue aiming to make a world that works for everyone.

Unshackling ourselves from the prejudices, and ideologies of centuries-past is a goal of social engineering.

And, a world void of social engineering, is a world full of dumbed people. "Stand up for change (1)."

(1) quote from Barack Obama
_________________________

The Big Yellow Box, to the Right:
http://www.xomba.com/the_yellow_box_to_the_right

I have believed in John Edwards for five and a half years.
I believe in Barack Obama, and have for two years.
I am a Libertarian.

VOTE BARACK OBAMA for PRESIDENT!
"...it is time to pass the torch from one generation to another..."
John F. Kennedy, Jan. 20, 1961

WRITE & Earn $$$
http://www.xomba.com/referral/7777ea2e

Read all my posts:
http://www.xomba.com/user/bigpink



Check out two of my favorite YouTubeChannels
Lots of Playlists - Organized Content - Much Variety
http://www.youtube.com/quinoacat

Old Vintage Commercials, Old Cartoons, Old TV Shows, Dogs, Martial Arts
http://www.youtube.com/wahwahwahwahwahwah

It does matter what you believe, but, what you believe does not matter if you do not act upon your beliefs.

you can not vote on the truth
--Pope John Paul II, 1995



kjhack's picture
Submitted by kjhack on Mon, 2008-05-19 21:30.

Counting change seems to be a lost art. You're right, technology has dumbed us down to a degree, since we are using our brains less and less for ordinary tasks.

I'm constantly amazed at the deplorable lack of English skills by young people coming out of our educational system. I know people who can't claim English as a first language who speak and write better than a great percentage of Americans. Now that's sad.

In my opinion, being a teacher is one of the most noble professions. And I agree with you, there is no room for incompetence when it comes to raising the next generation. It has to be a community effort too, like you say. Everyone should get involved, parents and non-parents alike, to ensure our children our getting the best education possible.

Social engineering has brought many positive changes to out society, yes. But of course, it has to be backed by the will of the people.

Great post! : )

Click here to read my stuff. It's really good stuff, I swear!


Click here to become a member of Xomba.



binkdonk's picture
Submitted by binkdonk on Fri, 2008-06-06 11:09.

How many people do you know, adults and children alike, that have trouble telling time on a clock with hands instead of a digital display?

Get Paid $$$ to Write! Join Xomba! www.xomba.com/referral/7778f814

Check out your weekly Tarotscope
http://spiritlightsinsights.blogspot.com



kjhack's picture
Submitted by kjhack on Fri, 2008-06-06 11:37.

Traditional watches just aren't as popular as they once were. Everyone has a cell phone, these days, so young people get used to keeping time with those.

I've never really been fond of digital readouts, myself. The only digital watch I ever owned was a Timex Ironman during a time when I was doing a lot of running. But I prefer a traditional dial because it gives more a sense of what time of day it is. I'm sure most oldies will understand what I mean by that. :)

kjhack's Xombytes

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

Join Xomba



Antonella's picture
Submitted by Antonella on Fri, 2008-06-06 12:00.

As Italian, I don't like watches: in my free days I put my watch away and I feel me free in my time:-)
However I think it is very important for children to know where they live and how some things run in the world: some children today miss what is really important in life.

Antonella's Xombyte

↑ Grab this Headline Animator



Free Cracker 4 Jack's picture
Submitted by Free Cracker 4 Jack on Fri, 2008-06-06 12:13.

I really enjoy watches, I collect them from time to time, (pardon the pun).

My current favorite is a Romilly Skeleton that is automatic winding when worn.

Anyway, you're right. Even my own children are not very capable of reading an analog clock face. :(

Guess I better start working on that!

FreeCracker4Jack
Would you like to earn money writing similar articles?
CLICK ME!

Read more great articles: http://www.xomba.com/xombyte/free_cracker_4_jack?p



Idlewild's picture
Submitted by Idlewild on Fri, 2008-06-06 13:10.

This is an old debate... not to say it isn't true in some ways, but every generation can point to things that are lost from one age group to the younger set.

In the 1940s or earlier it was felt by some that comic books were corrupting young minds, taking them away from serious reading. Radio, when it was new, was seen by some as a bad influence. And of course TV was called the "boob tube" at least as far back as the 1960s.

When I was in high school there was a big debate over whether it was wrong to let students use calculators in math and science tests (yes, I was in h.s. in the Dark Ages). Electronic cash registers eliminated the need for cashiers to be able to count change, as bigpink noted.

One of my first xombytes was about this college that puts out a list each Fall for its faculty, reminding them of the world their students grew up in... it's a fascinating list (students don't remember smoking on airplanes, the Soviet Union, or a divided Germany, or rotary phones)...

When Was the Last Time You "Dialed" a Phone Number?
http://www.xomba.com/when_was_the_last_time_you_dialed_a_phone_number



Free Cracker 4 Jack's picture
Submitted by Free Cracker 4 Jack on Fri, 2008-06-06 17:24.

Some great and inciteful thoughts from: SupaDupaFlyGirl







FreeCracker4Jack
Would you like to earn money writing similar articles?
CLICK ME!

Read more great articles: http://www.xomba.com/xombyte/free_cracker_4_jack?p