0
votes

Are Your Kids Being Poisoned On Their Playground?

posted February 28, 2007 - 8:27pm
Are Your Kids Being Poisoned On Their Playground?

"Good Housekeeping" magazine recently published a disturbing article relating the experience of a family in Ottawa, ONT., Canada. For weeks, in 2002, they had suffered from multiple varying symptoms including nausea, diarrhea, dizziness, burning eyes, and throats. They saw multiple doctors but none were able to diagnose their symptoms or offer them any help.

A few weeks into the puzzling illness that plagued the family, mother Michele, awoke in the middle of the night to check on their six-year-old daughter, Tessa, and found her babbling incoherantly in her bed. "Momma, da-da-da-da-da," like a baby. This was “a girl who had learned to talk early, and was reading before she even started school”. Terrified, they rushed her to the doctor again. Though her speech had returned to normal by morning, the episode was quickly followed by a series of frightening seizures, one after the other.

In the following weeks the family’s symptoms worsened to include terrible coughs, rashes over their bodies, burning and numbness in their hands and feet, and extreme exhaustion. Little Tessa was repeatedly hospitalized for her symptoms. Still, it would be months before they learned the source of the symptoms that were plaguing them.

During this time visitors to their house began to complain of feeling head-achy and sick after being there only a short time. This finally led them to wonder if there was something wrong with their new air-conditioning system. Wondering if this could be the source of their illness as well, they had a repairman come to inspect the system.

After crawling beneath the deck to inspect the unit, he came to report to Michele that the air-conditioning unit was fine, but he was very concerned about the "green puddles" under the deck. He explained to her that they were formed by rain water leeching the chemicals from her deck onto the ground below, and that it was the worst he'd seen.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Michele immediately realized that this must be the source of their months-long illness. Accordingly, their doctor quickly referred them to a medical pathologist, who soon attributed their apparently random symptoms to "acute arsenic poisoning". After a visit to their home himself, he indeed determined that the source of their arsenic poisoning was the lumber that their brand-new outdoor deck was constructed of.

Michelle was so angered that she dove into her own investigation. She subsequently learned that this same kind of lumber could be found, at the time, in 90% of all similar wooden structures throughout the U.S and Canada, and this spurred her into action.

***********************************************************

Known as CCA lumber, (Chromated Copper Arsenate), it is made by soaking the boards in a high-pressure tank full of water, which is mixed with huge quantities of chromium, copper, and arsenic. The process forces and infuses the chemicals deep into the wood, and is meant to preserve and protect it from insect infestation, bacteria, and wood rot. However, what kills the insects is also toxic and even deadly to people too.

Even more frightening, she learned, was that this same kind of lumber is used in the construction of playground equipment and structures in countless back yards, public parks, and school-yards across all of North America, and indeed the world. She further learned that there are still an estimated 70 million American homes with some sort of deck, porch, or structure made of CCA lumber in their yard.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Arsenic is a well-known poisonous chemical element. Exposure to it, even in small amounts, is proven to cause everything from cancer to brain damage, and even death.

Chromium can also be another powerful poison with its own list of dangerous and even deadly affects. It is probably best known as the chemical responsible for contaminating the town’s water supply in the truth-based movie, "Erin Brockovich".

This wood, when fairly new is easily identifiable by its greenish (or reddish) tint. As the wood ages, it turns gray, but the chemicals permeate the wood so deeply that the risk of exposure never goes away.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Both of these dangerous chemicals can be absorbed through your children's skin, or ingested by them putting their hands in their mouth and/or eating after playing and failing to wash their hands. Additionally, the chemicals are leeched by rain water from the wood and into the soil around the equipment. So even if your child is only playing around the equipment, they are at risk of exposure.

***********************************************************

The lumber industry is still quick to downplay the risks to children and points out that the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) and the CPSC (Consumer Products Safety Commission) never took regulatory action against them.

However, it is interesting to note that they only came up with an alternative treatment solution after the EPA and CPSC began health assessments of CCA wood. Most of the wood now sold is treated with a copper based mixture that so far appears to be safer to humans.

Manufacture of CCA wood for theresidential marketwas completely halted in December of 2003. However, it is still manufactured and available to the industrial/commercial market; meaning that CCA wood may still be used in structures used by the public.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

************************************************************

In a study published last November in the prestigious medical journal, The Lancet, Dr. Phillip J. Landrigan, professor of pediatrics at Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York City, says that exposure to arsenic, even in low doses, can significantly increase your child’s risk for bladder, lung, and skin cancers.

Included in that study was a list of 202 industrial chemicals that he believes are contributing to a world-wide ”silent pandemic” of brain damage and neuro-developmental disorders such as autism, ADD, and mental retardation. Of the 202 chemicals on the list, Dr. Landrigan says that, “arsenic ranks very high on the list in terms of these concerns”.

The EPA has since issued a draft preliminary report looking at the possible cancer threat posed to children by CCA wood still in use across the country. The data collected by one environmental watchdog group suggests that as many as 90% of American children face an unacceptable lifetime cancer risk from CCA wood.

************************************************************

So what can you do to protect your children now and minimize their future exposure? This link has information you need to know about arsenic, and offers instructions on how to remove the risks from your own home. Arsenic & CCA Wood

The site points out, not surprisingly, that it is illegal to burn CCA wood in all 50 states. Incredibly, a single 12' x 2” x 6” board has enough arsenic in it to kill 200 adults, and a single tablespoon of CCA wood ash contains enough arsenic to kill an adult human.

The salty taste of the ash poses an additional risk to livestock and wildlife animals alike because they are naturally attracted to the taste of salt. The site points to the case of a Minnesota couple who lost 18 of their Holstien dairy cows when they broke through a fence and ingested CCA ash from a pile that was illegally dumped near their property.

**********************************************************

This may be old news to some, but I think it bears repeating as a reminder to parents out there. If these structures are in your children’s playgrounds or school yards, become an advocate! Take an active role in pressing the schools and parks in your area to remove this equipment as well as the soil around it. Insist that the soil, sand, or material the equipment sets in be replaced to a depth of at least 2', and that the equipment be replaced with a safer alternative, such as pesticide free cedar or redwood, or even recycled-plastic composite lumber.

Don’t wait for someone else to sound the alarms, or for our government to step in and mandate the removal of this equipment. Your children are at risk with every exposure, no matter how small. Chances are if the equipment in question was built between 1977 and the end of 2003, it contains arsenic. The only way to be sure is to test it.

************************************************************

For additional helpful information, inlcuding where and how to order test kits to test any questionable equipment your children may be exposed to please use the links below:

To order a test kit:
http://www.ewg.org/reports/poisonwoodrivals/orderform.php?fromhost=safe2play

For instructions on the removal and disposal of affected equipment from your home or other areas; or if removal is not feasible, precautions you can and should employ until such a time as the equipment can be removed: http://www.safe2play.org/documents.html or
http://www.ewg.org/issues/arsenic/10tips.php

For a checklist to use to follow up on the equipment at your child's school, or any other playgrounds they may visit; how to have it tested and removed; the right questions to ask, who to talk to, and what to demand of whom:
http://www.safe2play.org/assets/docs/safetychecklist.pdf

Source article: Good Housekeeping/March 2007 by Virginia Sole-Smith

Lady:P’s Xombytes



Comments

Your children and arsenic

Thank you for the comment jc...knowing that I reached even one family with this is all the reward I need. I apologize for not including more information for you on how to follow up on your concerns. The link in the article offers a lot of good information, with links to many other informative and helpful sites. But I will go back and include a few of the links below in the article as well. Thank you again for your feedback. Lady:P Here are some other links that may be of help to you: To order a home test kit: http://www.ewg.org/reports/poisonwoodrivals/orderform.php?fromhost=safe2play There are three different kits you can order. The first is a simple swipe test for testing the wood in question. The second is a "Hot Spot" soil test to test the soil immediately around the equipment. Both of these tests sell for $20 each. The third test is a more "detailed soil" test of the soil away from the equipment, to establish how much if any arsenic is already present in the soil around your house. This one sells for $35. Each test comes with detailed instructions on how to collect the samples, and what you can expect to learn from the results. You take the samples yourself and send them off to a lab. You will get detailed results back in one to two weeks. The results of your test(s) will also be included in a national research program being conducted by the University of North Carolina Asheville's Environmental Quality Institute. This page, at the same site, offers a number of useful links for more information on arsenic and further reccomendations: http://www.safe2play.org/documents.html Amongst the links offered on that page are: Instructions on the removal and disposal of affected equipment from your home or other areas; or if removal is not feasible, precautions you can and should employ until such a time as the equipment can be removed: http://www.safe2play.org/documents.html or http://www.ewg.org/issues/arsenic/10tips.php A checklist to use to follow up on the equipment at your child's school, or any other playgrounds they may visit; how to have it tested and removed; the right questions to ask, who to talk to, and what to demand of whom: http://www.safe2play.org/assets/docs/safetychecklist.pdf Chances are if the equipment in question was built between 1977 and the end of 2003, it contains arsenic. The only way to be sure is to test it.

The building industry, your politicians, your

The building industry, your politicians, your local Mayors and BBB -- all people you know and love -- do not want to really talk about this. There does not seem to be much stopping Big Business from shafting your health and the kids health. Many craftsman work in wood, but do not mill these kinds of finished lumber pierces for obvious health reasons. Some may even assert the treatment helps sequester carbon! Which it does. One evil for another? Nice article, still timely. Lumber is getting very expensive again. If we could quit pumping carbon dioxide into the air we could cut lot of trees down and treat them with something else. http://www.leelumber.com/igsbase/igstemplate.cfm/SRC=DB/SRCN=/GnavID=12/SnavID=96 the site above talks a little about this and the 15 months the EPA is allowing the industry to change. The alternatives aren't too attractive either yet -- and they are now talking about ways of making their product more quickly 'biodegradeable' which means making it turn it's carbon back into carbon dioxide and float above to make more trees, all of which adds to the Carbon load in the air and greenhouse warming. There are some trade-offs that do not help all of us; again help only a few. Most man-made things that keep bacteria from a meal and protect the wood, so far aren't too good for the environment or the kids or the people, as you point out. Cedar and redwood are expensive natural substitutes, but not always as structurally solid as other woods. CCA is bad stuff! EPA not asleep, just slow.

Thank you for sharing this information.

Thank you so much for sharing this information. It's a shame that these manufacturers knowingly used this contaminant to make playground equipment. When my husband and I were looking at houses to buy and grow our family in, we fell in love with the house we're in now because of the play area in our backyard. It looks a lot like the play area pictured in the last picture. I now worry about the idea that it might be made of this wood.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member