0
votes

Asteroids, small ones, deadly on Mars or the Moon, harmless on Earth.

posted January 10, 2007 - 3:30am
Asteroids, small ones, deadly on Mars or the Moon, harmless on Earth.

Asteroids, even small ones, are deadly on Mars or the Moon, but harmless on Earth.

(Images from NASA)
`
-
The circles shown for scale on the NASA images are 12 km across. If you ran around the circles, you run a distance of 37.699 km. A Marathon run has been set at 26 miles 385 yards which is 42.195 km, so running around one of these circles would get you almost 90% of an Olympic run.

Of course, at the surface of Mars the gravitational pull of the planet is 37.9% of the pull of the Earth's gravity, a little more than a third. And with Mars, it's a reason the "air" is so thin an object the size of a football made of rock likely makes it all the way to the surface. Well made rocks, the size of a quarter also can reach Mars surface. A steel ball bearing that size would have a very good chance of making it through to the surface, depending on velocity and angle of traverse through the thin Martian atmosphere.


`
`
`

It's all about the air, there.
`
Your Great-Great-Great Grand children, those few living on Mars will know exactly what this image is about. On Earth it would have been a fireball, a bright meteor. It would probably have burned up at 50 to 60 miles overhead; halfway to low earth orbit; halfway to space. Even if it made it into the thick atmosphere at the tops of the Earth's highest mountains, it is likely it would never make it the surface intact.

`

-

On Mars it also can streak and burn, but if it starts its journey being a rock the size of a football, it makes it all the way through the Martian atmosphere and impacts on the surface.

It never occurred to early investigators that they would be able to see as many as twenty asteroidal impacts in a relatively small area of Mars, but they have their before and after impact images, like the ones shown here.

The eventual count of impacts over the entire Martian surface will refine the estimation of impacts on the Moon as well -- another small world we will have humans living upon before the end of the century.

Anywhere on Mars after a lifetime there, you would likely to have been close enough to see, hear or feel them. And be thankful one missed you.
-
-

http://www.nasa.gov/vision/universe/solarsystem

Use the link above and explore, or pickup the 8 December 2006 issue of SCIENCE (at your school, your library, or institution of higher learning. )

These are Meteors Hitting the MOON

After initially seeing what asteroids and anything moving in the 10 to 15 km/second range impacting Mars can do, it was easy to further push home the point that walking around on the Moon or Mars for a lifetime increases the likelihood of getting smacked and these hunks of a comet suffice to show that even comet-ice and dust can make a visible impact on the Moon. That is, visible from Earth.

In this case with every meteor shower the Earth experiences, THE MOON gets hit too. These 'hits,' on the Moon are not asteroids; these are chunks of rock or hunks of ices and dust strewn off of Comet Tempel-Tuttle (55P, the number means 55th periodic comet in a close orbit around the Sun.) Images of some recent impacts of the Leonid's Meteor Shower were captured. This is not a new thing, Amateurs see them often but are usually looking for the close ones, the ones in Earth's air!

According to NASA scientists, the meteoroids are smashing into the Moon more often than anyone expected. These meteoroids are in a tube shaped volume of space and retain much of the original comets orbital momentum, so are still circling the Sun in roughly the same place every year, until they run into Earth or the Moon.

Each red dot denotes a meteoroid impact observed since Nov. 2005 by members of the NASA Meteoroid Environment Office.

If correct, this conclusion could influence planning for future moon missions. But first, the Leonids:

Bill Cooke, head of NASA's Meteoroid Environment Office, says, after his team "observed" two Leonids hitting the Moon on Nov. 17, 2006 they were ready to let the recording equipment take over. "We've seen 11 and possibly 12 lunar impacts since we started monitoring the Moon a year ago, and that's about four times more hits than our computer models predicted."

Last month, Earth passed through the "minefield" of debris from Comet 55P/Tempel-Tuttle. This happens every year in mid-November and results in the annual Leonid meteor shower. From Nov. 17th to Nov. 19th both Earth and the Moon were peppered with meteoroids.

Meteoroids that hit Earth's blanket of air disintegrate harmlessly (and beautifully) in the atmosphere. But the Moon has no atmosphere to protect it, so meteoroids don't stop in the sky. They hit the ground.

A very few of these Leonids would also make it through an atmosphere like Mars' atmosphere -- if they are big enough.

But these are the debris of a comet, not chunks of rock out of the asteroid belt.

The vast majority of the Leonids are dust-sized, and their impacts are hardly felt, though in past meteor showers astronomers have recorded enough hits on the Moon to see gasses vanishing to space after impacts on the Moon's surface. Bigger debris can gouge a crater in the lunar surface and explode in a flash of heat and light. Some flashes can be seen from Earth.

During the passage through Comet Tempel-Tuttle's debris field, Cooke's team trained two 14-inch reflectors located at the Marshall Space Flight Center to image the dark surface of the Moon. On Nov. 17th, after less than four hours of watching, they video-recorded two impacts: a 9th magnitude flash in Oceanus Procellarum (the Ocean of Storms) and a brighter 8th magnitude flash in the lunar highlands near crater Gauss.

"The flashes we saw were caused by Leonid meteoroids 2 to 3 inches (5 to 8 cm) in diameter," says Cooke. "They hit with energies between 0.3 and 0.6 Giga-Joules." In plain language, that's 150 to 300 pounds of TNT.

Most of the Leonids are too small to make it through Mars weak thin atmosphere. Of the two Cooke mention's likely only one would make it to Mars' surface.

But the Moon has NO atmospheric protection!

http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2006/01dec_lunarleonid.htm

Unlike Mars, where we have orbiters constantly watching the surface, we do not have lunar orbiting spacecraft of comparable ability -- or none of this would be a surprise to NASA's scientists. Observational data trumps theory everytime. Yes, we need a capable imaging satellite orbiting the Moon, not two telescopes in the yard at Marshall. (Those are nice telescopes however.)

Now there would be some improvement in information before we go to the Moon again, and definitely before we go there to build a Moonbase.
Visit the NASA site; check it out.



Comments

Response to TheWonderer

Absolutely, our air is thick compared to Mars. Submitted by Les Porter on Fri, 2007-01-05 08:38. It takes a sizable chunk! to make it through Earth's shield! You look up day or night, but especially night, and all that is between you and the dangerous radiations and dust of space, is some air. Good stuff to have around you! When our brand of life arrives on Mars, explores it further, and finds the water we need, and maybe builds tiny or formidable habitats and domiciles, the things that fall from the sky are indeed dangerous on Mars. The rocks fallen in the last part decade of time we have been observing Mars with eyes sharp enough to see the changes falling rocks have wrought on Mars, we note most scales of objects crashing to Mars and seen these past few years would be harmless to a world like ours (Earth) with a hundred mile thick envelope of air. Yet raw statistics gets you if you walk around on Mars for a few decades, then surely as time and chance progress, one rock from space will land very, very close to you. In Mars' thin envelope, you might even hear the sound, and if small and close feel it, or be thrown around. The SCIENCE article states the current impact rate is normal and about what we would expect with nothing much over head. IF, Poof! we could WISH for Mars a Ball of Air, and magically it would appear and provide enough Air for us humans to breathe and walk around in, suit-less,and thereby naked in some cold Martian wind -- this Whiff of Air would only last 60 million years, but likely it would only be mere tens-of-hundred thousand years before the surface partial pressure would not give us a breath. That wish for Air, our wish, would wrap the Red Planet in an envelope -- for our little walk -- would be but mere hundreds of millenia in escaping to space and thinning so our breath would be ever shorter as time moves forward. Yet it is a place worth going to, a place our imaginations and some vast engineering efforts could turn into a world we could walk about upon. More likely, it will require space suits of some kind for as long as there is any desire to grow into other places in the essentially infinite space around us. Since there seems a drive we have with other life, to persist through time, we might go to live with some of it on Mars. So are we beings eventually going to be able to clothe the planet Mars in Air we can sustain to walk in on Mars, and an ocean of water deep enough to sail and a Mars, turned blue? Only if we really can command vast energies unto our will can we live long on Mars, replenishing waters and gases as they evaporate to space in Mars weak gravity. But Mars is the easiest one to think of realizing now. I have not worked the physics, but could, or suggest bright students here think through the numbers, and see when those pressures would be like ours here on Earth's homely surface or slightly more breathable than Earth's Everest, yet be on Mars' surface. The point the posting tries to make you read clearly! And that is what it takes to walk around on these smaller solar system objects, those ones without much air upon them is some pretty sophisticated technology or habitats well beneath the exposed surfaces. The impact/cratering rate in the inner solar system , demands this thoughtful approach, before one even thinks of walking a lot upon our Moon. This Moon of Earth, our Moon, we need to visit and try upon it's naked face to learn to master some tools we will need to spread across our Sun's system. Aye, be aware the walk upon our Moon is ever more dangerous than a walk on Mars. But it would be good practice, statistically. A great many colleagues, with hopes of finding that life can begin in any favorable environment, are going to continue, and should continue, to look for the ancient signs of beginning life on Mars. And who knows? We may find some ice-bugs when we humans get there. Life perhaps, in the remnant waters of Mars. Evolved as far as life could under the circumstances. Another question is do we Earth cowboys have an obligation to leave Mars if we find life there? I would have to say "What were the critters chances?", but some intelligences might say to us, "Keep'a yo' hands OFF!!" If you go there, bring a thick big steel umbrella, and walk around far under it.

BY TheWONDERER

I have to apologize. The comments to this little xombyte were well presented and there is/was a bug in the xomba input scheme that prevented it from actually becoming a real xombyte. When first posted it was there as a new posting but had no categories associated with it. . . so I am attempting to resurrect the questions and answers and the comments associated with the original rendition. Hear Ye! I am having to learn that this web site's implementation of the phpbb codes have significant holes in them and I have begun learning which bb codes actually work here on xomba. This is not a criticism, It is a fact. And any new effort is developmental. To get the images out and the thoughtful writing that is sometimes enhanced by images, YOU are going to have to learn what works here too. Imagine, War and Peace with pictures scattered throughout the text, a little help for some writers, but for Tolstoy, Pasternak, Joyce Carol Oates, Frost -- the images form themselves in the mind of the reader. I like images that way, but if you are speaking to observable tangible facts, images are a fact and work! Not many will read this, so xomba-admin, I have brought these out before! But it is an adventure! posting, learning HTML and BB codes etc. and what works as opposed to what might work! Back now, from the reason this has my picture on it. TheWonderer responded Interesting. If I understand TheWonderer's picture(lost in my attempt) Submitted by TheWonderer on Tue, 2006-12-26 14:33. Interesting. If I understand you correctly, you'd have a higher individual likelihood of making contact with a meteor living on Mars than Earth. But I guess the other side is that while the likelihood of meteor-human contacts are lower on Earth, when that rare meteor does make it to or near Earth's surface, the result is catastrophic and widespread.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member