0
votes

Is "Bipolar" disorder the new excuse for ill behavior?

posted May 16, 2009 - 10:00pm
Is "Bipolar" disorder the new excuse for ill behavior?

Bi-Polar disorder is described as a mental illness that affects a person's ability to control their state of mind. A person with Bi-Polar disorder experiences states of euphoria and also extreme states of depression. Both of these sensations can occur and change within a matter of minutes. I envision a comedy and tragedy mask as I write that sentence. I have not been diagnosed with Bi-Polar disorder; my daughter, however, was diagnosed with this condition 6 years ago. The disorder, however, went several years without a proper diagnosis. The doctors we saw could not quite put a finger on the problem initially. During the past six years, our family has been through tough times dealing with her mood swings and unpredictable behavior. The high school years were the toughest. We paid many visits to the school principal due to her escapades. There were times when I was not certain how we could help her; and also help ourselves. We visited several doctors in hopes of pin-pointing a cause in order to find a treatment. We finally hit the jackpot a couple of years into the seeking process. She was prescribed two medications. That was six years ago.

My daughter is now an adult woman. She aspires to achieve the highest of goals. I can see the determination in her. She still, however, struggles with her condition. I recall during our doctor visits while she was a teenager, the doctor would advise that-as an adult-she would be conscious of her behavior and work to circumvent a negative mood. That has not happened. I have noticed that when she does not get what she wants, she breaks into a manic behavior. She will yell, hit herself with whatever she can find, and threaten to hurt herself. On a few occasions, she has threatened to open the car door while the car is in motion. Even with the temper tantrums in play, I refuse to give in to her requests if I feel they are not reasonable. My confusion, herein lies, in the fact that after the episodes subside she reminds me that she is Bi-Polar and cannot control her behavior. I am always flabbergasted and do not understand how someone can allow themselves to experience extreme behavior. Why would anyone want to slip into a dark hole? I bring this to her attention in hopes that she will recognize the signs and symptoms and work to rationalize through the emotion in order to prevent the drama. So far, I am not certain I have made a positive impact on her behavior. I love her with all of my heart and worry that she will not be able to blend in successfully with society. Society is not as forgiving as your parents. As a child, I know my brother and I had issues with our parents. We acted-up and felt sad at times. I do not recall, however, the terms Bi-Polar or Depression ever being mentioned during those times. Now, it appears that many kids in todays society are suffering from this disorder. My question is, has Bi-Polar disorder become the new age excuse for poor behavior?



Comments

Blame it on a mental disorder

I have often felt that although some mental disorders are real, as with my brother, http://www.xomba.com/paranoid_schizophrenia_sibling_s_story I also believe that many children are misdiagnosed for the doctor/pharmaceuticals benefit and even would say for some parents as they can excuse the behavior instead of addressing it. With my sister, she was so afraid that her son would be schizophrenic that she took him to the doctor at any sign of unusual behavior. Sibling rivalry, once his brother was born, became a major concern and she just knew that the eldest at age 2 was mentally ill. I sometimes wonder if she manifested all the behavioral problems due to her own projections of fear. MJ - Sending happy thoughts and Smiles! Avatar: Betrayal and Retribution http://www.valkyrieart.com/Poser1.html

How to treat your doctor

mmm... MJ, if your nephews are that self-aware during their lucid times then I would look again at exactly what their "problem" is. Same with 'blessings', the OP. Also interesting that the criteria for bipolar are different in the US and Europe, so the definitions are symptomatic rather than biopsychological. Many conditions are a great way for pharmaceuticals to hook people onto their drugs for life, with the full support of government and the medical profession. I was diagnosed with epilepsy and took medications for over a year, but being a stubborn sod with a scientific background I kept plugging away at the doctors as I just didn't have the same experiences as other epileptics. This is where the collective niche knowledge on the internet is invaluable. Eventually I found one of the best epileptologists in the world who said,"In my opinion this doesn't look like epilepsy!" I've been medication-free and freely insane ever since! :-) The serious point is not to believe the doctors until you yourself are convinced. Mmm... that's maybe not right, as most people are at a disadvantage when they see a specialist as they need help. I've written on this... am digging out the link... gotcha! http://epilepsycures.blogspot.com/2009/01/how-to-treat-your-doctor.html It is a general article about How to Treat your Doctor. Another instructive lesson is how the Nobel laureate and mathematician John Nash managed his schizophrenia - don't have a link but easily searchable. Join Xomba Here

Bipolar - an excuse

Hi blessingsaskedfor, I totally understand your frustration. I have two nephews who had been diagnosed at a young age with ADHD and later the eldest with Bipolar. Of course, the Bipolar was diagnosed only after it became a "popular" diagnosis. They spent their youth on Ritalin. Anyway, I use to get so frustrated with my sister because she would excuse her sons' behaviors and expect others to do the same. "They are ADHD, they can't help it." My oldest nephew even got arrested for terrorist threat and expelled from high school. He wrote an essay of how he would kill his teacher. It was a creative writing assignment. Anyway, he thought it was funny and my sister explained it wasn't his fault.(Charges were later dropped) Well, her boys are now adults. 25 and 23 year old adults, who still live at home, with no job, and no ambition to get one. They are both going to college this year, but because of their "disabilities" are only taking one to two classes. I can't honestly say it is an excuse, but I can say that some people will take advantage of a disadvantage. Wish I could offer you more help in dealing than just understanding. I have often talked with my nephews about the situation and get so frustrated with their attitude of, "I don't want a job." and "I can't help it, it's the mood swing thing." that I have stopped trying to guide them, they don't want guidance, they want to be given things and unfortunately, their parents are doing that. MJ - Sending happy thoughts and Smiles! Avatar: Betrayal and Retribution http://www.valkyrieart.com/Poser1.html

Bipolar ....

Thanks a lot for this informative article. KaThaK http://internetjobs4uall.blogspot.com

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member