2
votes

Comet Holmes 17 P. You CAN See it. Don't wait too long! UPDATE. 12-01-2007

posted November 14, 2007 - 12:22am
Comet Holmes 17 P. You CAN See it. Don't wait too long! UPDATE. 12-01-2007

Comet Holmes 17 /P.

Unless you live in a place with pretty severe light-pollution or in a cloudy globally warmed climate -- you can see this comet with your naked eye. If you need glasses, keep them on -- and let your naked eye wander down the Milky Way from Cassiopeia's "W" toward the bright Capella. About half-way between Cassiopeia and Auriga's bright Capella, near the brighter stars in Perseus at least for the next several nights you can spot Comet Holmes. It will still be in this vicinity for a while, but could "fade to black" for small telescopes or binoculars in a short time.

1-December 2007. Okay. Tonight I am intermittently, well, mostly socked-in with wind, rain, and snow. But I just spotted comet Holmes as I walked in toward the house after some late chores. The southwest wind blew in a lot of moisture, rare for this time of year, at above 7500 feet. So it really warmed up and it is as muddy as late spring warming. The Comet is amazing! I saw it's blob tonight through a gap in the clouds that opened and blew by. I am amazed to find that the blob is still quite prominent, still much brighter than M-31, the Andromeda Galaxy, and easily visible! If you have clear darkish skies go see it. It is still easily third magnitude and is as the orbital position plot shows quite a ways now from Mirfak. I'd estimate at most 2-1/4 degrees and as early as I looked tonight "above", toward the zenith, from Mirfak. I am surprised it is still visible! Take advantage of it! Best through binoculars but still much brighter than the big Andromeda Galaxy. Has anyone spotted the nucleus at the heart of the blob in the last few days? I'll look online a few places. Amazing!

Sky and Telescope has several solid articles and many links.

http://www.skyandtelescope.com/news/11372856.html

It could outburst again, so it bears watching. It is fading(11-20-2007) the moon interferes with it in binoculars after my local midnight. It does not look like this now!

Image: Wikipedia
Photo of Comet_Holmes, with permission by author John Lanoue, at www.bedfordnights.com

It will look like this photo minus the distinct colors. To the naked eye, smaller, but this is impressive through binoculars or small telescope. Oh. You won't see the nucleus of the comet through the binoculars! But!!!!

It is impressive if things in the sky can impress you. It looks like a blob, as a blurry, fuzzy round spot, about 70% as large as the angular diameter of the moon in the sky. What you see of it is larger than the orbit of the moon around the Earth. . I've been observing it haphazardly since I heard it erupted into naked eyed visibility. Now my eyes are old. However on the 10th and the 11th of November just after dark, it seemed at least magnitude 2.0. Tonight, it is a little more diffuse maybe larger and perhaps 2.2 magnitude -- still a far cry from it's usual magnitude of 16 or 17 -- fainter than Pluto at mag 14 point something.

Whatever Holmes out-gassed in this eruption -- it made the object that you can see -- about 1,000,000 times brighter than normal. Through some 10 x 50 Celestron Binoculars, this object is absolutely impressive. It is like a ghost, and maybe the same color as one those haunters describe.

When this normally very faint comet "erupted" it became the second largest apparition in the sky. It can't last. Take advantage of this opportunity, and take some binoculars with you. Really, if you think about what you are seeing -- this is remarkable!

The orbital elements are at here:
http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/iau/Ephemerides/Comets/0017P.html


Image: Wikipedia

Where it is with respect to other objects. Currently it never gets as close to the Sun as Mars!

Image: Wikipedia

I will be watching Holmes as long as I can see it with binoculars. Then I might observe it for a while with my other scopes. It will be visible for quite awhile -- at least til this outburst dissipates itself to surrounding space, and the Sun's wind blows the ghost away. The comet will be there but it is normally faint. Jupiter keeps hacking up its orbit so for a long species time, it bears watching!

Image: Wikipedia, from Tomruen

UPDATE 11-16-2007

About 6:30 local, I grabbed my binoculars and went outside. Three of the Dogs had gotten out. I had been in Denver 3 days and had cataract surgery in my left eye. I might write a byte on that later. But my new eye lens is not quite as sharp as it used to be. But 36 hours after the knife and the acrylic insertion it is pretty good optically. It is now better than 20-20, but It is sore and there is an air bubble in the lens-cavity that the body will absorb in a day or three or a week.

Comet Holmes

The comet now is about magnitude 2.7 or so , and if you hide from the waxing moon it is diffuse and expanding so that through the 10x50's it's angular diameter through binocular is larger than 30 minutes (Larger than 1/2 a degree) The Moon appears to be about a half a degree, and the Sun too. (That is they subtend about 30 minutes of arc in the sky.) Comet Holmes is 1.6 Astronomical units away from us which makes it quite a bit larger in angular physical dimension that the Sun or anything else in the solar system but it is a ghost; what you see weighs very little. The Sun is roughly 865,000 miles in diameter.

1.6/1 = X/865,000 miles

X = 1.6 x 865,000 miles = 1,384,000 miles

It is a bit larger than that, likely over 1.5 million miles in diameter. How did I estimate it larger than 30 minutes. Really roughly. I compared the size of the moon in the binoculars with the size of the comet. The comet is slightly larger.

Tomorrow some part of the blob should pass in front of Mirfak, the yellow-white brightest star in Perseus. I am sure the pros with the equipment will be obtaining spectra to see what frequencies are being absorbed by Comet Holmes of Mirfak's light.

Just in, 11-17-07. 7:15pm local.

Holmes still visible naked eye, but quite diffuse. Moon at first quarter is not near the problem most people have. Even though I complain of the aerosols and dust, I have very dark skies.

I thought Holmes ghostly diffuse blob would be a little closer to Mirfak than it is, but it appears through the binoculars that only the very outer part of the diffusing blob reaches and intercepts light from the star. Since I am using 10 x 50's I know the apparition would be larger in a telescope of even 3 inches. (Yeah, I'm just too much enjoying the naked eye and small lens view to drag out the bigger scopes.)

This link will take you to JPL and you can see the orbit! with respect to the rest of the solar system , but you can advance or go to the past with the Java Applet. Give the applet and JPL site time to load. You can play with the future or past trajectory. I ran it forward to its next close major orbit changing encounter with Jupiter in December of 2050. Note the very comprehensive data available below the animation!

http://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi?sstr=holmes;orb=1;cov=0;log=0#orb

You need to Google Holmes 17/P and see what others are saying about this remarkable object. And look, most of what IS -- is OUT THERE . . .take a look.

Okay also see NASA's Hubble page on Comet Holmes.
http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/news/hubble-holmes.html

Also there is some science to be done in X-Ray and Chandra committed 8 hours and the observations were made Nov 1, 2007.

There are some x-rays!

Note that Scott Wolk calls it charge exchange.

I look forward to the images once posted at Chandra's site.

Read here:
http://chandra.harvard.edu/blog/

Dr Scott Wolk's blog is a kick!



Comments

Yes, you can see it.

This one is easy, but you need Binoculars to be sure! About 1 hour and 15 minutes after the Sun touches your western horizon and sinks below it, it will be DARK. Then you need to find a place where you can look north at Polaris and see it, 2nd magnitude, and have about 60 degrees of unobstructed treeless view to the east of Polaris. If you can see roughly 60 degrees east of Polaris you can see Perseus and where the Milky Way is below Cassiopia. By 7 pm local time your sky is as dark as it is going to get until people turn their sky-directed lights off. If you can see polaris, the comet is nearly that bright. By 7:45 or so local Comet Holmes in Perseus is roughly the same distance above the horizon as Polaris is, so you can get the rough idea that if you look at the part of the sky east of Polaris and about the same height in the sky as Polaris is above the horizon, you will be in the ball park and can see it. As soon as it is dark, take a look! It is up all night though by near dawn it is in the northwest going down. Try it an hour and a quarter to 2 hours after sunset and it is easy. Find a place you can see Polaris and now Polaris is just a little brighter than the Comet's blob. But not much and there may even be another explosive outburst -- but this is a long way "out" compared to Earth's distance from the Sun. Image: Wikipedia -- By Tomruen, Full Sky Observatory. On this image from Wikipedia, the Comet is the red marker in Perseus. Note that the whole sky will rotate around Polaris as the nigh goes on. By roughly midnight, the comet will be high near your zenithal meridian, directly overhead, kind of "straight" up. A recliner with an electric heater pad or just good back insulation like a winter coat would make it easy for binoculars. Holmes should be easy enough for a few days, but it could evaporate quickly in the solar wind, way out past Mars' orbit. It actually is larger than the Sun in angular diameter and will soon dissolve away in the sky. Sorry I did not clarify this earlier. It is a once in a lifetime opportunity. What kind of event aboard the Comet caused this out burst of gas the Sun's light has made visible ?? -- when normally you are looking at a 12-inch to 24-inch telescope just to see it, and here you do have a good chance to see it even in Jersey's light polluted sky? Each magnitude step is 2.512 times as bright or faint as the one step next to it. Polaris is nominally Mag 2.0 Most people in a clear dark sky can see magnitude 6.0. So from first to sixth magnitude is a ratio of 2.512 x 2.512 x 2.512 x 2.512 x 2.512 = 100 times in brightness. Holmes brightened by roughly a million times (100 x 100 x 100)nearly 15 magnitudes from whatever is normal for it at it's closest approach to the Sun (mag 16 , or 17, or 18). Good luck seeing it! It is easy.

Light pollution capital

Unfortunately, I live in the light pollution capital of the U.S. (or the East Coast, anyway). Any idea of when are good days/times to see in in the East?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member