The Europeanization of America - Freedom to Fail or Failure of Freedom
posted February 20, 2009 - 4:36pmAn interesting column on Reuters "Goodbye to rugged American individualism?" starts off with the standard right-wing Republican stance that somehow all the current government largesse is a lurch towards European-style socialism. The very title of the piece pits individualism with collectivism. But perhaps these Americans have just swallowed too much of their own country's anti-communist propaganda to see beyond the shades of red.
Data shows that indeed US government spending as a proportion of GDP has been edging upwards, although still shy of the European average. It concludes by saying that in times of crisis a social safety net is very much the business of government. Otherwise, what is their point? Yes, I know to take money from everybody and give it back to a few. Well, this is a time to give it back to the many.
But my reaction took the question a little further. Is all this individualist machismo such a real success? Is it just propaganda to make Americans feel good? Does the demand to succeed actually hamper real creativity? By various measures the US comes out about 15th in the world in terms of the best countries to live in. It excels in many fields and has the corporate muscle to make sure everybody else knows about it. But what about the charge that somehow European social democracy (not socialism) is anti-individualist? That is, after all, the charge that the right wing likes to make against what it sees as socialism.
In terms of politics, religion, arts, music and culture there are few places in the world more heterodox than Europe. In contrast, much of what comes out of America culturally is the same tired boring suburbanite clichés we've been seeing for decades. Does the drive for success deprive the culture of the benefits of experimentation? Does a social safety net actually make Europeans more individualistic than Americans? Britain is often criticised in the rest of Europe for being too American - this was certainly true in the Thatcher-Reagan years. But even in those days an unemployed person had a small allowance, free rent and a host of initiatives to get either back to work or to learn a new skill, often including subsidised university courses.
Ultimately a social safety net gives the individual the freedom to fail. In contrast the right-wing libertarians espouse freedom for the victors and poverty for the rest. Is this recession a failure of freedom?
To comment on this article Register for Free.
Make Money adding your own bookmarks and articles.
Earn extra money bookmarking your articles here...

Comments
we agree on something else, pub
Your Effort Failed
Who is Publius?
What is Rational Liberty?
How do I join Xomba and get PAID to write?
my last effort to convince publius that he's wrong
Yea! We're on the road to socialism!
political change
Join Xomba Here
See? This is what I'm
Who is Publius?
What is Rational Liberty?
How do I join Xomba and get PAID to write?
The fatal flaw of capitalism
Who is Publius?
What is Rational Liberty?
How do I join Xomba and get PAID to write?
federal reserve banks
Join Xomba Here
This kind of uneducated rant
Who is Publius?
What is Rational Liberty?
How do I join Xomba and get PAID to write?
So, how is corporatism and
Join Xomba Here
Post new comment