0
votes

In light of the plastic bag versus cloth bag issue...

posted July 19, 2007 - 9:13am
In light of the plastic bag versus cloth bag issue...

In light of the plastic bag versus cloth bag issue, I admit that I am probably one of the people among many who abuse the use of plastic bags. I don't just throw away most of them. When I had a cat, I would reuse the plastic bags to throw away her litter. Now I have a toddler and a preschooler. I go around and reuse the plastic bags to empty trashcans around the house from wet and soiled diapers. What bags I don't use, I place in the recycling bin.
I could go all together, without these wonderful plastic bags. I wonder what would happen if everyone stopped using these convenient vessels. There is so much petroleum put into these bags. I am not an expert in what goes into making each of these bags (that would be a great research topic for a future article). I am just speculating that we would save a lot of petroleum that could be used elsewhere - - like in conserving some of our oil and gas resources, and helping us stay away from middle eastern sources. Like I said, I am not an expert, and anyone can educate myself and others on what an impact (or lack thereof) this would make.
What would make it much more easier for me to convert to cloth bags would be an in-your-face marketing of these products. I haven't seen them anywhere where I would be thinking about buying them or needing them. Why don't they sell them in the supermarket? They could have bundles to buy. If you're a single person, who only uses about 2 bags during a typical shopping trip, you could buy them individually to fit your needs. If you're a couple, you might use about 5 bags on an average shopping trip. They could have a couple pack for the newleyweds and roommates, etc. If you're a small family maybe 7 to 10 bags would be ideal - - hence, the small family bundle. If you're a medium sized family...Well, you get the picture. Marketing research could be done to see what the best numbers would be. I think the more in-your-face the marketing is, the better. It's kind of like what happens when I'm waiting in line at WalMart, and I see the dog toys at the checkout line. I buy one for our dog, because it's there and it's in my mind. I think that's what end-cap marketing is all about, too. Am I right? The other day I needed aluminum foil. How convenient it was to see it on the end-cap. I went ahead and put the product into my cart without going down the aisle where they would be, because it's easier on me when I have 2 kids in the cart.
It's not that I don't want to use cloth bags. About once a week, I take my girls to the library. I used to use the plastic bags that they'd offer for free. Then the handles would break after a couple of trips. I foraged through a stash of things I'd forgotten about in our coat closet. There I found a cloth bag that was given to me free from a workshop for legal education. Now I bring that with me to the library every week. What we can fit into the bag, we check out. What we can't fit into the bag, we leave behind to check out on a future visit. It works. Don't get me going even further. I think there are several articles being harvested from this topic that I could do...



Comments

Not saying that using other bags is bad...

There is a difference between you voluntarily using a backpack to bring your purchases home and the recent trend toward banning plastic bags altogether, but still using the petroleum in other areas of people's lives. Life in America is geared toward the consumption of products requiring petroleum in their manufacture or for shipment. Until Americans get away from the consumer mindset and return to a lifestyle of "live simple so others may simply live", trends like what San Francisco is doing are really not much more than gestures.

Cloth (and other) bags do make a difference

Yes, they definitely make a difference. I take a backpack with me to the store to put my purchases in. Yes, some resources were made to manufacture the backpack, but that was 10 years ago when I bought it. I've been using that same backpack for years, which has saved many thousands of plastic bags that would have to be made and then thrown away.(I use plastic bags as garbage bags, but I don't generate nearly enough trash to use up all the bags I would accumulate in just a couple of weeks.)

Cloth Bags: Do they really make a difference?

I believe that the only true "environmentally-friendly" carrying container is what you can carry in your arms. Will cloth bags help? Maybe a little. But, unless someone were to grow the material in their own backyard and hand-sew the bag, the bags are trucked in from somewhere and other resources are used in the manufacture of the bags (not to mention the trucks involved in bringing the raw materials to the factory. If I were to see an impartial study done on the benefits of cloth bags on the environment, I might be more enthusiastic about this latest fashion trend. But, as of now, I view it as another form of elitist hypocrisy. How many of those faux environmentalists in San Francisco fill their cloth grocery bags with food that was trucked in from other parts of the country and climb into their gas-sucking Beemers or SUVs and drive to their air-conditioned, electricity-draining homes? It's not any different than what happened in the 1970s during the Oil Embargo when we were told to ride the bus to conserve gas, but the people telling us to ride the bus would never be caught dead riding public transportation. Yes, I am generally wary many things, but, being from California, I am much more so about things coming from the Bay Area. San Francisco is the city where city employees are allowed to have sexual reassignment surgery using taxpayer dollars, after all.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member