0
votes

Is The Internet Making Us Stupid?

posted October 27, 2008 - 9:58am
Is The Internet Making Us Stupid?

When was the last time you read a book?
A real book, with no hyperlinks and no embedded videos.
When was the last time you read beyond a few paragraphs online?
That itch to click got to you?
Has wisdom become byte-size?
Has the man-machine become a drone?
Why invent robots when humans can be turned into automatons.
Every revolution in storing and distributing information has had its critics. But the methods of production have also influenced what is written and how it is read. Or are we going back to a medieval world of illiteracy and visual information?
Has the rush to be informed stopped us from thinking?
Some of the more self-aware thinkers are finding that the very structure of information on the internet is leading to a kind of paralysis of thought.
The answer is surely the next click away.
But the mathematics of random walks has a cautionary tale to tell. People assume the random walker staggers around the straight path, but this is not so. In most cases our peripatetic surfer will stray far away from the initial route, possibly only coming back after a very long detour.
Perhaps as we reach a crescendo of information overload we come to the realisation that none of it is really, fundamentally important.
In an open world there are times to close the doors and concentrate on one thing.
What is important?

Now click this - you know you want to.

The last click is the one that goes off in our minds.



Comments

I will paraphrase for the empty chair

That may be so, but there is a comment gone missing. I even remember more or less what it said. It complained that my title was wrong - though I'm not sure that a question can be right or wrong. And it said that the internet was the best thing in the world since... well...ever, and that we should be grateful for all that information. That may be so, but the article was about not just using the internet as a research tool but as the actual interface with which to gain knowledge - different things. Money for your Thoughts - join now OWO-BV

Negative Outlook on the Nature of Man

You say the Internet makes us into automatons. I would rather think that the Internet simply helps us see what automatons mass-media has made us into. Someone clicks a link that's planted in the text of an article, they click it because they choose to. (Sure, maybe some kiddies on super-fast computers are entrained to 'climb every mountain, click every link, open every page, read every word, etc, etc.'; but most people have 'things to do.') ---Uncle MythMan & we Xombies Explain Money, Love, God etc. Work w/ Us to Find Yours! WAKE UP! ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ..

---when You Join Xomba, you can join this- and MythMan's other-hot discussions!

@R.M--Maybe They'll Add That, but For Now Comments Work Like ...

... recent personal-history---you were 'somewhere,' you said 'something'; all parties affected can agree to remember 'what you said' and/or 'how it made everyone feel' differently than the original, but you cannot change 'that you were there' nor 'that things were said.' :-)) ---Uncle MythMan & we Xombies Explain Money, Love, God etc. Work w/ Us to Find Yours! WAKE UP! ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ..

---when You Join Xomba, you can join this- and MythMan's other-hot discussions!

Can users delete their own comments?

I was going to reply to a comment here I saw yesterday... but the comment has disappeared! How can that happen? Users cannot delete their own comments, can they? I guess one can flag one's own comment and request it be deleted, but why? It wasn't offensive, or insulting, nor particularly embarrassing... so where is it? Maybe I imagined it, maybe I've finally been online too much and should unplug myself. Maybe it isn't so important. It's all impermanent. Money for your Thoughts - join now OWO-BV

I dont agree with the title

I dont agree with the title of your xombyte at all! internet is a boon for all of us and because of these hyperlinks and videos only we have been able to build platforms like wikipedia,etc(Also xomba!) Internet has come so handy that we cannot restrict ourselves anymore Thanks

defragment the mind

yeah, strange analogy, as that's the way a computer allocates disk space. Hence sometimes need to defragment! Money for your Thoughts - join now OWO-BV

Interesting

It's like disassembling a book and putting a few pages of each chapter in amongst other books of a library. We may eventually find all the page locations and read them as we go, but we have lost the continuity of the information in the quest to assemble the story. I have never been one for reading books on the Internet. I would much rather buy the book used in the Amazon Marketplace or on ebay and sit down in a comfy chair with some music on than read it flat on my computer screen and scroll instead of flipping pages. Even printing out the pages to read later isn't the same as reading a book for me. DO YOU HAVE THE WRITE STUFF?

we remember nothing

yeah, almost! :-) or a Dylan song. The article linked to was not so much about recalling so much info. After all, we almost don't have to remember it as we can bookmark anything. But that this mosaic of information leads to fragmentary thinking. That trying to hold a logical argument becomes hard work as the next colourful little tile is just a click away and we butterfly off. I do actually sometimes switch off my connection and read through a whole book on pdf. I find I can actually remember a lot more doing that than if, for example, each chapter came from a different website. Somehow the narrative becomes one voice, one train of thought (however complex). In contrast, the internet is a tower of babel. Channel hopping does not mean we remember little bits of lots of things - we remember nothing. Money for your Thoughts - join now OWO-BV

This could almost be a John Lennon song

I know he sang "Mama told me there'd be days like these", which is what I thought about when I read this article. It's like with the Internet "everyone's always talking and nothing being said" but also "there's so much information and nothing's being learned". Our brains have tremendous capacity for learning and intaking information, but the speed and volume of the Internet overwhelms our conscious recall of that information. Many people read their news on the Internet, but being bombarded with all sides of an argument is too much, so those people end up of FoxNews.com reading what they would otherwise be watching on TeeVee. Then, there are those who text/IM all the time and whose language ability has devolved to "hu r u?" and nonsensical abbreviations. Even when I used to use IM to communicate with people, I made it a point to capitalize and use punctuation. All it took was learning how to type faster. DO YOU HAVE THE WRITE STUFF?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member