0
votes

Mommy Wars: Stay at Home Vs. Working

posted September 7, 2006 - 9:03am
Mommy Wars: Stay at Home Vs. Working

It seems women are perpetually at war. We painstakingly make decisions for ourselves, our bodies, our families, and when that decision has been made, we feel the need to fight to defend those decisions. Whether moms should stay at home or work outside the home is a contentious subject to say the least.

Stay at home moms resent what feels like social demotion upon their decision to stay at home with their children. Meanwhile mothers who work full time resent the implications that their children suffer because they are making a living for their families. In the end, I believe what all this dissention amounts to is insecurity in our own choices.

I have been on both sides of the fence. I have worked outside of the home before pregnancy, during pregnancy, and after pregnancy. I have had children in childcare, and have worked during school hours. I have also been a stay at home mom, I in charge of nothing more than dirty diapers, naps, meals shopping, and paying bills. Eventually I have settled into being a work from home mom.

There are many benefits to being a stay at home mom. The first is being able manage your life according to the schedule of yourself and your family instead of your employers clock. Being a stay at home mom means you have more time to spend with your children, and that there is a greater chance that your home will be in order (though there are no guarantees).

There are many benefits to being a working mom. The first benefit is having adult conversations during the day. (I vividly remember the days when I would have given anything to talk to a “big person” during the day.) Working moms also have the benefit of having their own money ad not having to rely on their spouse when the want to purchase a piece of jewelry or get a pedicure. Believe it or not, stay at home moms; many working women actually love their jobs. Corporate America is an intriguing world. There is tons of mental stimulation, exciting projects, and interesting people. Working can be fun, when you want to do it.

The downsides to being a stay at home mom are draining. Imagine being the only woman on your block at home during the day. There is no one to go to when you need emotional support or just a bit of companionship. Work-at-home mothers often feel unappreciated and overlooked in spite of their obvious talents and value.

The main downside to being working mom is feeling conflicted. Work at home moms are missing many of the firsts of their child. To work outside the home when you have, a child is a huge sacrifice of spirit. The monetary exchange however, may be necessary to survive, or even impossible to turn down.

There are hundreds, even thousands of reasons why a mother would want to work outside the home, or to stay at home. It is highly unlikely that the two sides will agree any time in the foreseeable future. I personally believe that the mothers who do most of the griping, sniping, and snubbing of and at one another are the ones who are not happy and secure in their current positions. Many stay at home moms would love to work, at least part time. Many working moms would rather be at home. Circumstances and timing for neither may line up, however.

If we as women could learn to be happy in our own circumstances and support our sisters instead of berating them for personal decisions based on circumstances we know something about, we would all be better off. If your desire is to be in the other women’s shoes, perhaps you should take some time to look into other alternatives. Finding a way to work from home, perhaps by teaming with someone from the opposite camp, (as each has the experience the other needs) might make everyone happy in the end.



Comments

Well Put

I agree with you on your point that we need to be happy where we're at.  It's really sad that moms want to bash one another for making different choices.  I am a stay at home mom and I believe that my choice does have it's strengths, but on the other hand there are downsides to it.  If you would have asked me six years ago if I was going to be a stay at home mom I would have told you no way.  Life changed my choice.  I had to stay at home because I never had the support I needed to continue working.  I'm not any better than moms who work, but I'm also no worse.  I also would like to point out that there aren't just pros and cons for women staying home.  There are also pros and cons for the kids.  You just need to decide what's best for your family and situation and go to bed every night knowing you made the best decision for your family.

From a stay at home mom

I agree with you on the point that we should all be happy where we're at. I am currently a stay at home mom. I was previously a 5th grade Reading & Language Arts teacher. When I was teaching, and my older daughter was in daycare as an infant, I always felt guilty that I couldn't be at home being a major influence in her life (rather than a person who was making roughly $7/hr to watch her being her influence). Now I'm at home with her and her little sister, and I wonder what I'd do if something happened to my husband, because I'm losing a lot of credentials being out of my field for a while. I would get a lot more out of life if I could just learn to be content wherever I'm at. My husband is also gone quite a bit, because he works overseas. I see him every 90 days. So I really have a hard time having no adult conversation. That's why i'm part of a Mom's club in my neighborhood, eventhough I only participate in something about once a week. It helps, though, and things like this help. I have to keep my mind stimulated. I enjoy your articles, and hope that I can be a part of a stimulating community here on xomba.com.

I like that you tackled this

I like that you tackled this subject with pros and cons on both sides and didn't necessarily take a side. I think it's difficult for anyone to really side one way or the other because there really are positives and negatives for both options. But I think we should cross-reference this post with the post entitled "License to Parent". I would have liked to see some input leaning toward the direction of what is best for the children as well as what is best for the mother. I think people tend to be far to selfish these days, and people who can only think about themselves and what they want and need should not have children. I'm not saying that this applies to any one general group, I'm just voicing my opinion.

I really liked this

Cecilia I really liked this. Someday, when I have kids I wan't to stay at home and see all their baby steps and their boo boos.

Cecilia

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member