0
votes

NO ESTATE TAX...

posted November 10, 2006 - 12:08am
NO ESTATE TAX...

As i see it there is nothing wrong with an estate tax. it is not like they take all of your money just some of it. Your family still gets to get 2 million untaxed and then taxes apply. the money is taxed exclusively for education and only applies for roughly 250 wealthy households. therefore obviously it does not effect you or me. we only stand to benefit. since it goes to education it indirectly benefits us. why should 250 households get tax relief when ultimately public education would suffer. The common citizens would end up getting a tax increase while 250 household get a tax break. hardly fair don't you think. we have a social and moral responsibility to make sure everyone has a decent education and if 250 household have to spend a portions their millions for social good is that really all that bad. granted they lose some money but they still are gonna be rich. tell me what you think.
______________________________________________________________

My response is as follows:

You must be kidding me!? Sure fact... "is not like they take all of your money just some of it." That's easy if your inheritance is tangible like cash, stocks or bonds. What if you inherit a family business or a real estate portfolio, those things aren't tangible. Many families have invested every penny and bit of their sweat into running a successful business. Hypothetically, let's say my parents die and I happen to inherit the business. But guess what, the government is going to make me sell the business at a loss to some multinational corporation because I have to cough up this so-called estate tax. My family had worked their lives for nothing.

Further, just because this may not affect you shouldn't be a good reason to forget about morals. Another hypothetical situation:

My parents made some money and paid taxes on that money. (That's fair).

Then in event of their death...

The government comes and tries to steal more money... guess what... it's because they became deceased.

Where's the moral in stealing money from someone whose already suffering from the death of loved ones.

Double taxation in general isn't fair. Where's the American ideal of capitalism and free market??? Double taxation just leads us closer to a socialist society.

There are other ways to raise money for public education. Government funds are being abused daily. Besides, public education isn't in any trouble. Since that is an unrelated issue, it will not be discussed in this forum.

Money isn't the real issue. It's the principles of the estate tax that deeply terrorizes me.

-Adrian

Source: http://noestatetax.blogspot.com



Comments

Technorati Profile

Technorati Profile this is not spam it is suppose to link this to technorati -thanx

o rl y

o rly?

when you sell property you

when you sell property you shouldn't be taxed? when you make any sort of money you are taxed. that's the way tax works. if you went to a 9 to 5 job and earned that money making someone else rich, guess what, you'd be taxed on those earnings. the same as making a profit by selling land. it sounds more and more like you're simply against taxes of any kind. yes i'd be more than willing to pay more on taxes knowing that it would go somewhere worthy. i HATE having to pay for things like a trillion dollar war, multi-billion dollar companies demanding free hand-outs, and defense contractors bilking the pentagon. things like that i think we can do without.

Apologies

Adrian, sir, I should have known by the spelling, please accept my apologies for starting that 'rumor'. I apologize to you as well, Pub. I misunderstood your comment...taking it to mean that HE could copy all of it, except the manifesto and lottery remarks. I see now that you meant those weren't part of your 'humble opinion'... I look forward to hearing from 'your' pet goat....

Dude looks like a lady?

Adrian's profile says he is male. Just noting this so we don't give him a complex or anything. Publius quoting Karl Marx? That IS funny. A couple weeks ago it was Darwin. What's next, "My Pet Goat"?

Lady...I told Adrian she

Lady...I told Adrian she could copy the whole thing, so I don't know what you're talking about. But I am funny, so thanks.

Yes, mobius, you're exactly

Yes, mobius, you're exactly right. When you sell property, you should not be taxed. How many times does the government need to tax the same piece of land? And I don't remember saying that you weren't taxed on stock profits, so how am I "wrong?" I also know what number 3 says...you must have missed the point, which is nothing new. I guess I just can't believe how much you love taxes. Perhaps you'd be willing to donate more of your own money for the "common good."

so publius...

so pub, i guess you think that when you sell stocks or bonds you shouldn't be taxed then either? when you sell property at all you shouldn't be taxed? is that what you're saying? cuz that's what happens. you have to pay taxes on the money you make from selling stock at profit. i just really can't believe how often you're wrong but how often you think you're right. oh and if you read number three again it says ALL RIGHT OF INHERITANCE, not a pittance after 2 million. AFTER 2 MILLION. *shakes head* and this mostly coming from what has NOT been taxed already. please stop your lying already.

Ditch the Manifesto, quick!!

You brought those points into the debate, but you don't want Adrian copying 'those parts' to her blog?? I don't think I would either, if I were you. You are so funny!!

You may. It's just my humble

You may. It's just my humble opinion though, except the part about the Manifesto and the Florida Lottery.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member