Should CPS Be Allowed to Take Your Kids Away, For Your Beliefs?
posted July 12, 2008 - 11:34amI wrote a blurb last night about the Canadian woman whose children were removed from her home after she drew a swastika on her daughter's arm, and sent her to school twice like that.
Now, my initial knee-jerk response is to be glad that these children were removed from a home in which their primary caregiver is a neo-nazi (apparently, she describes herself as a "white nationalist", and her home is covered with neo-nazi flags and symbols). I do personally believe that this woman's beliefs and politics will harm her children, and push them to become ignorant, racist buggers them selves.
However, the more I think about it, the more I think that this is really a bad thing. Sure, I don't agree with her beliefs and I think that they are wrong and dangerous. But, there's no evidence which suggests she is violent in her wrong and dangerous beliefs. There's no evidence which suggests that she physically harms, neglects, or endangers the children.
So, it got me thinking. Should CPS, the police, the school system, whoever be allowed to do this? Should they be allowed to say, "we don't like you, nor do we like the way that you are raising your children to believe in the same things that we don't like, so we're taking them away!"
What if you ran into a CPS worker that didn't like the fact that you were Muslim, and found those beliefs so wrong so as to endanger the children who would grow up around them? Would it be okay to remove children from the home of a Muslim, because someone didn't like Islam? What if the parents were gay? Do we remove their children because we don't agree with their lifestyle? What about Christian? Do we remove the children because we feel the beliefs held by Christian parents will endanger the child's ability to live and think and believe in the way we think is best for them?
At what point do we decide that even though we don't agree with the beliefs, politics, religion, lifestyle etc. of the parents, it is still not okay to take away or limit their parental rights because of it? When it affects us and our children and our beliefs directly? Where do we draw the line?

Comments
I'm not as confident as you that this will stop there.
Losing Weight and Feeling Great!
A Day in the Life of a Pagan Parent
The Funtabulous Stuff of the 80's
Nazis
I may have even been that kid!
Losing Weight and Feeling Great!
A Day in the Life of a Pagan Parent
The Funtabulous Stuff of the 80's
I agree with that.
Losing Weight and Feeling Great!
A Day in the Life of a Pagan Parent
The Funtabulous Stuff of the 80's
Perhaps
Losing Weight and Feeling Great!
A Day in the Life of a Pagan Parent
The Funtabulous Stuff of the 80's
Life has a way of righting wrongs
Simple remedy
Who is Publius?
What is Rational Liberty?
How do I join Xomba and get PAID to write?
YES and NO
Beliefs
Post new comment