0
votes

Small Rust Belt Cities Often Unable to Adapt to the Modern Economy

posted July 24, 2007 - 1:24am
Small Rust Belt Cities Often Unable to Adapt to the Modern Economy

Small rust belt communities continue to struggle in the modern service oriented economy. The great economic booms of the past quarter century have invariably bypassed the minor population centers of this region.

The rust belt itself is an area of both large and small cities and towns, whose economic existence was based almost entirely upon manufacturing and it's coincidental support services. Geographically, it encompasses much of the midwest and continues eastward into Pennsylvania.

As manufacturing operations moved to the southern United States and overseas, rust belt communities entered an economic decline that continues today.

Some larger cities have been able to adapt to a degree. The renaissance of Pittsburgh and Cleveland are good examples. Booms in health care, technological research, and large scale real estate development have helped these cities regain some of their former glory.

Unfortunately, large scale service industries do not necessarily work well in small cities and towns.

These were often physically located to take advantage of river, rail, and highway transportation. They are rarely located near a major airport and generally have outdated infrastructures and housing. With city coffers now depleted from the loss of their former industrial tax base revenue, improvements are often impossible. This is further compounded by limited funding from the state and federal government.

Another major hurdle to economic development is the population itself. High unemployment and underemployment have driven away many of the younger, better educated citizens. Those who remain are mostly from blue collar families who have strong, long term local ties. They are often financially unable to afford higher education. And, can sometimes simply be ill-suited by educational and social background for adapting to corporate culture.

Pedanticism tends to run rampant in community politics, creating a difficult environment for compromise. This is sometimes further complicated by outmoded forms of city government and high taxes.

The problems faced by rust belt cities are numerous. The lack of capital to invest in improvements to infrastructure, an aging blue collar population, and ineffectual local government have created conditions where adapting to the modern, service driven, world economy are often very difficult at best. In the worst cases, simply impossible.

The preceding comments are the opinion of a life long resident of a small western Pennsylvania community. They are not intended to demean the strong work ethic and labor background of most rust belt inhabitants. They are simply the observation of a common man. Some regions have successfully experienced economic recovery. To them, congratulations are in order.



Comments

The Rust Belt

Thank you so much for this article and please keep writing. My grandparents came from a little railroad town in Ohio and a no town at all in the hills of Kentucky. Few people realize that there are still parts of our country where indoor plumbing is a symbol of success in life. Some of the greatest moments of my childhood were spent on a porch in the hills with Great Aunt Elizabeth. The creak of the rockers on her chair, the sound of the snap beans falling in the pan and the birds and critters in the woods defined the moment in time. Angel

Work and Hope for Growth

Farns - Thank you for the comment. Hopefully you will find conditions improved in the future. I guess the part that worries me is that if improvements are forthcoming, they may alter the character of many communities too much. I like most aspects of the region and people. But, some of those characteristics are part of the problem. The politics and some infrastructure problems have solutions, if the right attitude (and intentions) are applied. Many of the social background issues are what trouble me. I just can't picture the thousands of Billy-Bob's in our area (me either for that matter), sitting through sensitivity training without standing up and shouting...NO Sir! I will not do it!, and throwing an empty Skoal can at the human resources supervisor. Let alone being able to handle college. Of course, they would also expect to be off on the first day of Buck season. Ha..Ha..Ha Seriously though, there is a clash of cultures over a very wide chasm. And, some very independent, hyper-conservative, and hard headed folks around here. I'll keep watching, listening and sometimes posting rust-belt life as it unfolds.

Excellent observations

I was born and raised in north central Ohio and I identify with everything you are saying. I joined the military after running out of college money because this area had no opportunities for me. I want to move home someday because I do love the area and the people but in the 10 years I've been gone the economy here has not improved significantly. I could look to Cleveland or Columbus I suppose. Since I'm not a big fan of cities though I must hope and dream that someday the smaller population centers such as Ashland, Mansfield, Wooster, Mt. Vernon, etc. will adapt and become places to live comfortably again.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member