0
votes

Spare the Rod and Spoil the Child

posted August 7, 2007 - 1:50am
Spare the Rod and Spoil the Child

The headlines in one of todays leading tabloids was about 3 children's whose hair was cut due to Bad behaviour. A few days back here was one about a principal in a rural school in Andhra Pradhesh who gave shock treatment to a child to make her improve her grades. He felt by scaring her she would study better but it had the exact opposite effect on her, she refuses to go to school with the fear of having to face the same ordeal again . But the saddest one was of a teacher in Uttar Pradesh who beat a child to death because the child was talking in class..........it is so sad that in this day and age when we have advanced so much we still use such harsh means to control unruly behaviour.....
That was a thing of a past when our parents would smack us on our backside for all our mistakes and the smacking used to be so hard that we would not be able to sit for nearly an hour after .........but we as children did not have as much emotional baggage as the children of today.
We were so used to being shouted at and reprimanded in public ........try doing it with one of the kids of today and are you in for trouble. The tantrums they throw are enough to make Shakespeare's Shrew in 'The taming of the shrew ' a well mannerd lady.
But jokes apart we have to find a solution to this problem...........why do teachers have to take such drastic steps......................
I have a few observations which I would like to put forward:-
For one , the children of today have much more exposure to things so they HAVE to be handled with care You cannot just say something and expect them to follow it blindly, they will ask you WHY and you have to be able to answer it.
Secondly I also feel the quality of teachers have come down ...............I still feel its not thedegree that follow your name like a BEd etc that make a Good teacher but they have to be someone who is Good with children and makes the learning process a very interesting and challenging one.
Thirdly our eductaion system being the way it is as a Teacher you are eternally wanting to be upto date in completing your syllabus and instead of having to rush at the end, so you end up loading yourself and the child ........thus making studies not a very pleasureable thing but something you just have to get over and done with.
But then I guess all this still does not justify the physical abuse on those little minds and bodies of those hapless things who are put into the custody of the teacher with the good faith of their parents.
We have to find a way by which we don't have to take such harsh and ruthless steps to control children...........after all the Children of Today are the Society of tomorrow ..............and as we sow so shall we reap so lets try and sow something good so that we can reap some even better.



Comments

Beatings are not okay but light spanking is

I spanked my kids and my grandkids as well. It is NOT against the law to spank your child on the buttocks a swat or two not with a club or board but with a light switch or hand. Never upper body and never head or face. Then ONLY for the very severest of situations. Example when they are endangering themselves or another person. Small children need hugs and cuddles and kisses. Often a firm word or two is very effective. Children want to please. I too was beat and abused and know what a belt across the face is and cuts and bruises. But the bible does tell us and as far as I am concerned it is God's written word does tell us to use a rod on the back side. A rod is not club. There are other ways of using a rod as well. Shepherds had a shepherd crook or staff sometimes they would just hook gently a sheep or lamb and gently nudge it to an area where it needed to be. But yes I feel at times a spanking is warrented. I have a son who would most likely have been killed on a highway if I had not spanked him one day when he kept climbing over the fence at age three and going up onto the highway. Thankfully when he did there was not any traffic but as I got there a log truck was coming and he was right on the edge of the road. I had a willow switch and spanked him for dangerous things. Telling him no, time out and everything else HAD not worked. After that if his older brother even got close to the fence near the road he would come tell on him and he himself never went up on the road again. There are times it is necessary but not for every little thing. As to man made laws and or Gods well I choose Gods even if it means prision or thrown in a firey furnace or a lions den. God did have a human instruction book we humans just don't like it and don't want to follow it or utilize it. If we did we would have a lot less crime and rebellion

Celanith

Hello everyone, stop and set awhile.

Child Abuse is Never Okay

Even as recent as my parent's generation felt it was okay to physically punish a child to "mold" him or her. I, myself, am a survivor of child abuse because I had an alcoholic stepfather who would physically, mentally, and emotionally abuse my two brothers and me, while my mother sat back and did nothing to stop it. Now that I am a father, I am determined to the core of my soul for my son not to have to experience what I did, so my wife and I continue to study alternative ways to discipline our son when he does need correcting, as all children do from time to time. What doctors and psychologists have found is the concept of "cell memory", which means the child's reaction to being beaten gets "locked into" his or her physical body. The danger of this, of course, is that the abuse can perpetuate when that child has children of his or her own later and the cell memories bubble back to the surface, often in completely spontaneous ways. A mild-mannered parent that is completely opposed to corporal punishment may suddenly lash out at his or her child in the heat of the moment because of past experiences as an abused child. I guess what I'm saying--in agreement to the original article--is that people as individuals and societies in general must avail themselves of new understandings and evolve if we are to move forward from comparatively barbaric practices of our past. The common defense for those parents who still beat their children is "my parents did it to me and I turned out okay." To them I say: Child abuse in any form is not okay.

Nice article

read your article and liked it. It is becoming a very serious issue lately as more and more such news of children being punished harshly in school by their teachers is brought to light by the media. Today's news also features such an incident where a child was in a state of shock in a hospital due to severe beating taken at the hands of the teacher. Another shocking incident also was reported earlier wherein a child succumbed to his injuries and died in the hospital, again, due to severe beating by the teacher! I wonder what is being done about this by the Law! and whether our govt agencies or the education ministers will take this issue seriously enough and do something about our education system!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member