The Absolute Irony of Public Transportation
posted August 19, 2006 - 3:41pmA few months ago, when America was still vehemently protesting the high gas prices by whining about how much they were paying to fill up their Hummer once a week, I read a newspaper aricle addressing this issue in the Star Ledger, a prominent New Jersey paper. The writer, whose name I believe was Fran something, attacked the people of New Jersey, saying we have no right to whine and complain, that we should be riding our bikes to the corner store, walking to the part with our children, and taking public transportation to our jobs.
This was all well and good if it applied to more than 30% of our state. No one can really say that New Jersey is in the middle of nowhere, but New Jersians also know that the further south you travel in this state, the more difficult it becomes to get anywhere. I happen to live in highly disputed Central NJ, where it takes a half hour to get to the grocery store, and gas gouging is a common practice, since gas stations are twenty miles apart. This can be expected in somewhere like Nebraska (no offense) where you can drive for three hours and see nothing but corn and grass (or so I've heard).
Public transportation is a way of life for those people living in North Central NJ, where busses run from Newark to NYC, you can walk to the train station, and subways exist. However, it is nearly impossible to use public transportation in the other 70-80% of the state.
My example follows. I recently accepted a job offer located in Newark. I live about an hour and a half south, and decided to take the train, since I have always wanted to use public transportation, for numerous reasons including but not limited to current gas prices. I bought my monthly ticket, parked in the lot, and took the stress-free half hour ride squished next to a man who fell asleep on my shoulder. When I returned that afternoon, there, stuck to the windshield of my car, was a parking ticket.
"Permit only."
This didn't irk me quite as much as one might expect. What irked me was that the only place that wasn't permit parking were some 10 spots a ten minute walk from the station. I accepted this graciously, parked in the other spots the next morning, and enjoyed a short walk to the train. When I reurned that afternoon, there, stuck to the windshield of my car, was a parking ticket.
"No parking before 9am."
I then approached a train station employee and asked how much a permit costs. She said, in a dubious tone, "There's a five year waiting list."
"Well," I replied, oh so sweetly, "where can I park then?"
"Get here early and park in the daily lot. It's $3 a day to park in the numbered spots."
The next day I drove to the elluded to lot and subsequently found out that the lot fills up at 6:30am, and there is no other place within a twenty mile radius to park for the train station.
I drove to another station. There was considerable parking available, for the cost of $.60 for the first two hours and $.30 every hour therafter...metered. That's $18 in quarters per week, not including the extra fee for taking that train to the original train station.
How, Ms. Fran at the Star Ledger, am I supposed to take public transportation then? They could make gas $4 a gallon, and it would still cost less than public transportation, and at least I could find a parking spot.

Comments
Quiet trains...
I lived in Manhattan for a couple years, and riding the train was an almost inescapable part of life: it was a necessity for getting to work. I do remember feeling like a sardine, and one time a woman actually groped me. On mornings where I wanted some fresh air (ha!) and more space (relatively speaking), I would my bicycle instead -- braving streets that are always brimming with homicidal taxi drivers.
Yet some of my most memorable experiences from NYC involve being on the subway, with only saw a couple of minor bad incidents. Riding the F train in Brooklyn, the tracks are elevated and one can see the Statue of Liberty – not a bad thing to have to see on a daily basis. I could write numerous stories about the characters i witnessed on that line alone. Maybe i was lucky, but i made eye contact with people frequently, and even had a couple of romantic stares back (well, that's my version of what happened). But you are right; it doesn't feel proper to strike up a conversation on the subway.
As far as public transportation in that part of the country, i was well versed in it, and always impressed with how well connected everything seemed to be. To elaborate: I had a job where i had to drive cars individually (to deliver them) from Elizabeth NJ to either the 5 boroughs, Long Island, upstate NY, metro areas of NJ, or PA. After i dropped the car off, i would have to figure out how to get back to my apt in Manhattan. Where there is a will, there is a way...i only got stuck overnight in one town (Reading, PA) because i missed the last bus out. Nonetheless, one of the best things about the Mid-Atlantic Seaboard is the Northeast Corridor Amtrak Metroliner (not always on time, but hey).
Food for Life!
This realllly hits home.
This realllly hits home. From one who lived in Berkeley.
hah, that's true. it makes
hah, that's true. it makes it hard to fight the war on war. vespas maybe?
Something needs to change
You're absolutely right. It's a shame we live in such a "private" culture. I find myself loath to the idea of driving with a stranger to work, even if they could become a close friend. Riding on the train itself is somewhat eerie, the way everyone avoids eye contact. The train, which I would have originally assumed was a loud, public place, is nearly silent during peak hours. It's amazing the way we all fear each other, or just have no interest in communicating in any way with strangers. It's such a shame, and I don' even know how it got that way.
But you're right about the fact that I should be complaining to, say, NJ Transit, and once I get my voice straight I will certainly be writing a letter, to say the least. We have something like a 2 billion dollar budget in NJ thanks to our new governor, but I can only imagine that most of that will go toward making roads even smoother for commuters sitting one to a car, yapping on their phones, bitching about the guy who doesn't immediately press the gas when the light turns green. We're all guilty of this. Something needs to change.
Very engaging piece...
Thanks for sharing your experience. I have lived in several cities; those that had excellent public transportation were generally more appealing places to live.
As far as suburbs go, we are looking at a big problem: they are designed for cars. In the 21st century will prove to be a fatal flaw for suburbanites -- who will eventually be paying upwards of 10 dollars for a gallon of gas (laugh now, cry later).
Another huge problem is funding. Voting for jackass politicians doens't help the situation. Complaining to each other about public transportation is marginally helpful (if it raises awareness of the problem), but also can just turn more people off to the whole idea of not driving solo.
Let's complain to municipalities and tell politicians that we are going to vote for the candidate who gives even the slightest crap about transportation alternatives.
Food for Life!
Hear, hear!
I live in Raleigh, NC, and it's much the same. No one is really trying to say "shame, shame," but I'd really love to be able to take public transportation. It's just not reasonable. It takes me about 10 mins to drive to work. It would take about 2 hours to take the bus.
Post new comment