The Passion of the Xombie (with apologies to M. Gibson)
posted March 5, 2007 - 1:53pmI started writing this as a response to "What's Wrong with You People" by Publius, but it kept getting longer and longer. Once it got to be three times the length of the original post, I figured it should be a xombyte of its own rather than one of the longest comments in Xombadom. And also it might have more of a chance of getting read and maybe spark some more conversation on what we all want out of Xomba.
I'd been thinking recently of a couple of the things that Publius mentioned, namely: 1] Lately there have been lots of short posts; and 2] In general, there have been very few comments made on posts.
And, he asked, "What happened to the quality, creativity, and passion here?"
As for the passion, here's one answer: some of the folks who were the most, um, passionate got so passionate that they got themselves booted off the island. And some of the other old-timers seem to have wandered off or return only occasionally.
Regarding the two points above: I think part of it has to do with money. The referral contest has brought in a lot of new people. Some may not exactly be here to write quality content. None of them were around in Xomba's early days, so they don't know what the site used to be like. Also, there are many ways to earn a bit of money online these days; many of the new users are probably using Xomba as well as a number of other sites for this. They maybe didn't hear the "writing site" part of Xomba; they probably just heard "write anything more than 25 words and earn some money."
So they're spending a bit of time at several sites, rather than a lot of time at Xomba. In the early days of Xomba, it seemed there were a lot of us spending a lot of time here. Of course, that had something to do with money, too--there was a contest going on then as well: users earned points for posting and commenting, so it rewarded users for adding comment after comment. Some comments were very good, others were obviously made simply to earn points.
I agree about the community feel; the original xombies would come and post, read other folks' stuff, make comments, etc. Maybe some of the newbies are more likely to post something here then go off to the next site with earning potential.
From a writing standpoint, longer articles are better than the very short ones.
From a financial standpoint, there may be no difference, or shorter might even be better. If a person wants to earn some money and has 30mins to spend on Xomba, it might make more sense to them to write several xombytes on different topics than one longer xombyte on one topic. More xombytes equals more page views equals more ad views and more potential clicks. With a very short article, you can also see the entire article plus all the Google ads in one screen with no scrolling.
My suggestion: increase the minimum words to 100 or more. 25 words always struck me as too short, except for poetry (make it so a xombyte can be 25 if it's in the Poetry category). Xomba is a writing site and let's face it, it's hard to really say anything meaningful in 25 words. This will probably upset some people who make short postings. Maybe they'll write longer posts, maybe they'll leave Xomba. Writing quality will probably go up, but clicks might go down.
Like any enterprise, there's a tricky balancing act between the desire to have quality and the need to earn money to stay in business and grow.
If anyone else has thoughts on all this, feel free to post comments here or on the original post by Publius (link above).

Comments
This was really interesting!
Bare Essentials
Conversion
It took what? 7 weeks to convert me.
Xombie passion
Hi, I am a Faith Builder who
Hi, I am a Faith Builder who helps people find more faith in God. You can checkout more of my writing at: http://www.faith123.com
I also help people in their fifties and sixties who are part of the new middle aged group find work at home opportunities
Like I said...scripts aren't
Who is Publius?
What is Rational Liberty?
How do I join Xomba and get PAID to write?
Welcome to CSI Xomba, Pub and friends. One version.
Argh! Posting problems, double post...
Tom Clancy was an insurance agent,
Hmm...script-writing. It's
Who is Publius?
What is Rational Liberty?
How do I join Xomba and get PAID to write?
Post new comment