0
votes

Twi-Light Material

posted November 24, 2008 - 12:10pm
Twi-Light Material

There’s no doubt that vampires are among one of the sexiest of supernatural monsters. The blood sucking creatures that are supposed to frighten and intimidate women have ironically been attracting them for decades, mostly starting with sensual vampire king himself, Dracula. So it’s no big shock that the tween generation no doubt enjoys them too, as that is the age that most younger people start developing a fascination for the opposite sex. Which is why the book series ‘Twilight’ has taken off like vampire bat out of Hell. The book series about a romance between a high school girl and her vampire love interest, has taken our youth by storm and continues to melt young girls hearts with its fulfillment of temptation and romance. That’s all fair and good, but how does the new film version hold up? Well, if this is a sampling of the books’ best material, I can easily say it’s view worth skipping.

The story is about a high school girl named Bella (Kristen Stewart), an awkward introvert who splits with her mother for awhile to live in Forks Washington with her divorced dad (Billy Burke). The two don’t talk much, which works out well for both of them as they have very little to say to one another. The school she goes to is a little strange (though I’m not sure if that’s intentional or unintentional) as kids introduce themselves to her out of nowhere and blindly decide to be her friend. At first I thought maybe these kids were the vampires, but nope, you definitely recognize them when they walk into the room. They all wear white clothes, a mountain of hairspray, and enough mascara that would make Marilyn Manson blush. They claim that they keep the secret of the vampire well, but I think even a blind werewolf could spot them rather quickly.

The one vampire who grabs Bella’s attention the most is Edward (Robert Pattinson), who seems to spend most of his time looking tormented in public and then claiming that he doesn’t want to draw attention to himself. Bella is of course drawn to his emo personality but doesn’t suspect that he’s a vampire until he saves her from a truck by stopping it with his hand. As Bella starts to pry deeper, she discovers that he IS a vampire, as is his whole family. But it’s okay, they’re described as vegetarian vampires (yes, you read that correctly) who don’t drink human blood, but rather animal blood (I don’t think that technically counts as vegetarian, but that’s a minor problem compared to the rest). The real, human killing vampires it turns out just came to town, and are threatened by Bella’s relationship with Edward. So Edward’s family tries to hide her away from these villains as they roam across the country tying to track her down. Why? Simply because they enjoy the hunt. Odd, seeing how they could have their pick of anyone across the United States to snack on.

The movie doesn’t always make a whole lot of sense, and when it does, you’re often distracted by the over the top writing and mediocre acting that the rest of the film is offering. Nobody talks or acts like real high schoolers, but then again nobody did in High School Musical 3 either, so why did it work there? I think it’s because HSM3 was tailoring to what grade school kids thought high school was like, and in a way there was a sweet charm to that. In this film, it seems like an uninformed writer’s interpretation, which of course is neither real nor interesting. The vampire world they create is not very gripping or detailed, the romance has no chemistry, and even the effects seem very Photoshopped at times.

I’d say the only relationship in the movie that came close to working was that between Bella and her father. They seem estranged, but they don’t hate each other or push each other away. They both make an attempt to understand the other one’s problems, and I think a lot of that is due to Billy Burke’s performance, as he plays a quiet but well meaning father. Every other performance seems pretty over blown, even for a tween film. It’s almost as if the creators, instead writing a story based on instinct, looked at the formula of what tween girls liked and tried to simply tie them together in a movie. While there is technically no sex or anything too gory in this picture, the film comes dangerously close to pushing the limit for younger viewers. Edward’s temptation for Bella’s blood can easily be connected to a teenager’s lust or sex, which would be an interesting development in an adult movie, but in a kid’s film it falls flat. There’s also scenes of people pulling out glass from their legs and getting bitten on their arms, which again can somewhat extreme for it’s ideal audience. But to be honest, I don’t think that’ll be the element that turns them off, it’ll most likely be the total lack of character, romance, and interest in what should be a relatively juicy story.

So who’ll like it? Maybe tween girls who are fans of the book, but even that’s a big maybe. A heard a lot of younger girls laughing just as I was at what were supposed to be more serious moments.

Who won’t like it? Most adults and teenagers (especially males) will be bored or uninterested. I think even true die hard romantics will have trouble finding any semblance of emotion between it’s two stars.

My thoughts? I never read the books, so I can’t really compare them. I only pray that children are reading something better than what was portrayed on the screen. The idea of relating high school with awkward responsibility of trying to blend in as something different like a vampire is not a bad one. If more thought went into this, it probably could’ve worked. Instead we have a formulaic, uninspiring and inventive romp that seems more interested in selling tickets and being popular than actually telling a decent story. Much like the vampires themselves, this movie really knows how to suck the life out of you.

Douglas Darien is a featured writer for Xomba.com. Read the rest of his work here or visit his website www.thatguywiththeglasses.com.



Comments

So in Other Words, Take Your Girlfriend to "Twilight"

You know, so that you both can make it better by discussing the characters' 'feelings' throughout ... in between makeout-sessions ... When "Inside Catholic" reviewed *Twilight-, I got the idea that it's more like "Harry Potter for Older Teens." For those of us who grew up in a deluge of Buffy-cized media (in which nothing "mundane" EVER happens), we kind of categorize the 'mundane' thoughts (e.g. emotion, judgment, etc.) as 'chick flick'-material. But InsideCatholic critiqued it they way I would, paying the 'mundane' more credence (as 'feelings' are the entirety of 'what movies actually give us') ... they focused more on the 'turmoil of Edward-wanting to be close to her but -fearing a rise in his hunger-for-blood.' I guess InsideCatholic tells more 'how to like the movie' than your 'who will/won't like it' Your way is okay for here (where everyone knows exactly how they are), but our way is okay for everywhere (where change is possible). ---Uncle MythMan (http://www.geocities.com/jmythh2k5) & the Xombies Bring-about World-Peace by Discussing Your Opinions on the Beauty Above & the Beauty Among!

---when You Join Xomba, you can join this- and MythMan's other-hot discussions!

Twilight

i waited SOOOO long and have read the books countless times.....and i read stephenie's blog just about every day.......i am EXTREMELY let down with the movie..... i went to the midnight showing and it was terrible.....bad acting...badly made....bad make up...... you never even found out that Jasper had a power it doesnt say anything about it...and the were-wolves were most certianly not horse size....like stephenie wrote them as!!!!!! haha good luck getting renessme to ride a dog in Breaking Dawn. i'd give it a 1 1/2 to 2 stars........just because robert is SOOOOOO hot they made it WAY more sexually and action related...they took the whole passionate love story...... ...love the books and vampires....hate the movie.....i hope they make New Moon much better. >Laura

From what I hear,

not a big hit with the teen girls either. My son just informed me he has received a few texts from his female friends saying, "The movie sucked." I am a controversy. MJ

oh, and, the guy was pretty

oh, and, the guy was pretty sexy too, ha

i fell in love with the

i fell in love with the movie so fast. i thought it was just a preteen thing, but man i loved it sooooooo much

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member