13
votes

We Need a Fifth Estate: Citizen Journalism

posted March 25, 2009 - 6:50am
We Need a Fifth Estate: Citizen Journalism

The Fourth Estate is dead. Suffocated by an avalanche of lies and propaganda, it is obvious that corporate mainstream media no longer serves its lofty ideals but is, rather, the tool of its masters. Does anybody truly believe what the corporate media says? Sadly, I think most people do, and therein lies the problem – propaganda works.

What is the Fourth Estate?

The term Fourth Estate usually refers to the function of the free press to investigate the truthfulness of the other three Estates, and goes back to at least the first quarter of the 19th century. In Britain the three Estates were the Lords Spiritual, Lords Temporal and the Commoners. Even in France, without a House of Lords, the tripartite division still made political sense and constituted the clergy, nobility and commoners. Thomas Carlyle quotes British politician Edmund Burke as exclaiming that up in the Commons Press Gallery “sat the Fourth Estate more important by far than they all.”

The press has been keen to propagate its own self-importance. In a democracy it is indeed vital that issues be discussed openly and arguments dissenting from accepted wisdom be at least aired without fear of any physical reprisals. But this is all highly idealistic. The word 'free' must be the most abused word in the English language. The free press is supposed to imply that it is free from outside interference but in reality the press is merely free to disseminate its own agenda.

The so-called mainstream media is owned by private individuals through corporate vehicles and is there purely as a propaganda machine to disseminate news that serves the interests of its owners. This can be blatant, as in backing a particular political candidate, or more covert, as in burying news that is seen as damaging to their own corporate interests. As corporate media is really no better than corporate advertising, why do people still believe it? And most people do still believe what they read.

The Fourth Estate is Dead

I was recently involved in bringing to light a story that Fox News had broadcast but then buried. The problem with having live guests is that they do not always tow the corporate line. This happens regularly in small ways. The financial press will often bury comments from analysts that do not agree with their pumping up of stocks. This attempt to ignore a valid analysis is a good pointer to its true value. But using the media's obvious bias to somehow extract the real story can be tiring.

The case of the Texas Senator being buried by the whole corporate media was eye-opening in how thoroughly the cartel operates. Although this is now 'old news' the lessons are important. A small number of online bloggers had seen the live TV interview and commented on it, only to then realize that the news had disappeared. There really were zero references to the interview in any corporate media outlet – that piece of news just did not exist! It never happened!

Most people think of themselves as being smart, street-wise, able to discern what is true and what isn't. But in this case, most people came across as children in need of parental guidance from the same mainstream corporate media sources they like to blame of bias. Now, you cannot simultaneously believe and disbelieve the corporate media. Either you understand what is being fed to you, or you don't. Either you believe what individuals are saying, or you don't. The sad fact from this case is that the propaganda works. The alternative media sources are actually powerless. However many non-mainstream sources there are on the internet their readerships are pitifully small compared to the corporate behemoths.

It is good to be critical about what one reads on the net, but this must surely apply to all news sources. If the corporate media has buried a story it is the height of folly to expect the same media to verify a story that it does not want you to know about! And yet this is what many people tried to do. They charged the bloggers with fabricating the story. Why would anybody fabricate a story citing a live interview that perhaps millions (probably just thousands) of people would have watched? Eventually, two copies of the Texas interview came to light, both proving that the original story was true in essence, if somewhat exaggerated on specifics. By this time the covert political machinations had resolved to play down the whole issue, as it became obvious it was not going to remain buried for long. The bloggers were vindicated but this was no Watergate and, unless I'm mistaken, there was no lasting follow-through. However, the lessons are stark – the Fourth Estate is dead, long live the Fifth Estate.

A Fifth Estate Needed

The Fourth Estate, in the shape of self-interested corporate mainstream media, is no longer there to serve the interests of its readers, assuming it ever was. Yes, I'm sure their sports results are accurate, but that's about as much reality as one can expect from news that is spun so much as to be largely fictional. If people really want to know what is going on in the world there really must arise a new Fifth Estate – a citizen journalism.

As with any new term, the Fifth Estate has already been used but in a multitude of ways, from a term to represent the poor, trade unions, organized crime as well as for bloggers. The book Watching the Watchdog: Bloggers as the Fifth Estate by Stephen D. Cooper, published in 2006, explicitly connects internet journalism with the much needed Fifth Estate. There is nobody guarding the guardians now, apart from individuals who are in the right place at the right time, with a story worth telling and, most importantly, a media outlet on the internet.

The internet is at the same time global and local. Every web page is there on your screen. Wherever the server, the editors and the writers might be doesn't matter – to the user everything is just a click away. There is therefore no excuse to keep begging at the altar of corporate media for 'faux news'. There is no excuse for swallowing lie after lie when there are far more honest sources of information. Being aware of the propaganda and the newspeak is useful in knowing what one is expected to believe, but there is no excuse in actually believing it. There are alternatives, and they are as accessible as the corporate media sites – just a different click away!

There is no excuse for slavishly following the corporate media propaganda, unless, of course, you've swallowed so much of it that your discernment has all but vanished.

from Article Network

To comment on this article Register for Free.
Make Money adding your own bookmarks and articles.
Earn extra money bookmarking your articles here...

Free Internet TV Channels
On Writing Online



Comments

Alison Hill Since the

Alison Hill Since the nineties, conglomerates have gobbled up independent commercial news entities, leaving very little diversity. I was lucky enough to work at a PBS station after moving to the States, and was given much freedom - tackling issues largely ignored elsewhere - The Patriot Act, GM Foods, etc. I went freelance mainly to pursue life-long dreams - creating documentaries and writing books. So far I have made two docs, completed a horror novel and am writing a second. I also have a work-related memoirs in progress. I still make the occasional political program, cover U.S. issues on BBC Radio Wales and write articles. But my biggest joy now is fiction... Again thank you for writing such an interesting article. By the way - I'm curious to learn what you were doing at the House of Lords?

Alison Hill

I was trying to figure that

I was trying to figure that out too - MJ?? Now I got it. Makes sense now. Read why I like to write for Xomba and how I've earned $3,000 in a month writing articles like this here.

why freelance?

Hi Alison, thanks a lot for your comments. Parts of it remind me of sitting in on House of Lords Select Committees - quite astonishing that the public can attend these, with or without a press card, although I had an invitation. Going back to the idea of the Fourth estate, surely that is precisely what investigative journalism should be - as distinct from rehashing press releases and spinning news to suit the paper's political agenda. The UK is strange in that it is easier to sack a politician for some sexual misdemeanour than for serious mismanagement of public funds. From what you're saying, sounds like the freedom you felt in the 90s has gone. Is that why you turned freelance? Join Xomba Here

Alison Hill Excellent piece

Alison Hill Excellent piece and very well written. As for journalists needing to attend college - I'm on the fence. I'm a trained newspaper and television investigative journalist who later became a TV Producer for PBS and am now freelance. I have an Emmy-nomination and have worked on BAFTA nominated/winning shows. My degree was in American Studies and I learned journalism on-the-job, in the trenches, under real deadlines. We were sent on short courses in law, writing, politics, shorthand, etc. but the real learning was actually doing the job. Writing an article in 15 minutes with interruptions, working to persuade lawyers at the TV station to allow a sensitive piece to be aired. Sitting in a council meeting or in court, giving the editor the lowdown on a story from a phone box in bad weather. Talking to people in the community, local government, going undercover with an alleged cult and secretly filming (one of my many assignments) How can you learn this in a classroom? You can glean the essentials like law and writing skills, how to use a camera and a mike, but unless an individual can perform under pressure, these skills become obsolete. In the UK back in the nineties I worked for a commercial channel - ITV (HTV Wales) and back then we had a lot of freedom, for example I did a story criticizing the Royal Airforce on the danger of low-flying jets. This story took me almost a year to research and gather all the elements needed for a 30-minute show. Now journalists are either lazy or don't have enough time to conduct research. Or maybe they do the job to feed their own ego and not for the overseeing function it should be and once was. Most British journalists do not have 4 year journalism degrees, at most they take a year-long course after their BA and then it's the real world training camp. You do learn most from those who have been doing the job for years, they are the best teachers and not professors in a classroom. This is not to demean journalism degrees, all I'm saying is that a degree is only the start and can only teach you so much. And whereas citizen journalism has a place, I do feel there has to be some standard in order to call oneself a journalist. It is a profession just like any other and if any person off the street can suddenly become a journalist it devalues the title. You must earn it through knowledge and experience. Oftentimes stories from such sources are just as biased as the mainstream media, full of emotion and anger and do not do justice to the cause or issue. On the other hand there are some who can present information with balance, objectivity and integrity - if a journalist can achieve this, trained or not, then they are on the right path. Something does need to change however and thank you for this article and discussion. I would recommend checking out FAIR - Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting: http://www.fair.org/blog www.serenmediaproductions.com

Alison Hill

I was comparing the effects I felt

I was comparing the effects that I felt as the same. The energy drinks taste horrible, too sweet, so they turn my stomach and the palpitations you mentioned are horrible, reminds me of the feeling when I overindulged. I honestly don't know how people stomach the flavors. : ) Once I experienced my trip to the ER, I was unable to take speed because I would start to feel sick and honestly, got scared of a repeat performance or worse. Of course the ER episode was a three day coming event. Lack of food and sleep and the body rebels. Admittedly, I was not very responsible back then as far as my experimentation. I also realize I am easily addicted to such things, so for me, staying away is the best path. I do have friends who still partake in marijuana and when I see these 40 and older people zombied out and unable to carry on conversations, focus on tasks or even life, it saddens me and frustrates me. The memory losses that are evident to everyone but them is also a frustration. About the spider web, many people who take speed, referred to as "tweakers", are also very clean and organized. Speed, as long as it is not mixed wih something else, has a focusing effect, I don't know the chemistry, but I have seen enough to know that aspect of the effect. However, any drug, legal or otherwise can be misused and abused and have detrimental affects also. MJ - Sending happy thoughts and Smiles! Avatar: Betrayal and Retribution http://www.valkyrieart.com/Poser1.html

Hi Beaker guess its a matter

Hi Beaker guess its a matter of intonation. Wasn't disparaging your degree - I assumed you had one from your comment. I had friends who went straight into journalism after doing a completely different degree. There was also a time during which I had quite a lot to do with journalists, from both sides of the camp. I've seen companies buy news, I've seen journalists trash perfectly good stories, I've stopped interviews when the message wasn't getting through. It's all spin. One thing worth learning is to treat journalists like lawyers - never speak to them, always correspond via something that you can keep a copy of, just in case you need to demand a retraction from the publication. As for the poor citizen journalist without due training, well I figure they come with the same range of abilities as those trained. Join Xomba Here

Silly

Rycharde Manne, your comment is just silly. Yes, I have a journalism degree, and of course it took longer than a month to learn everything there is. People who put down people with degrees are often expressing jealousy that is misplaced. There's no reason to be so angry that someone learned and studied. You said "What did the diploma or degree teach you?" which just shows that you don't really understand what goes into it. There is so much that it can't be completely encapsulated in a comment post. There were years of training in newswriting, AP style, how to properly and legally gather information, the laws that pertain to specific groups, copyright law, etc. Even one of the many courses and practicals took longer than a month, but you believe that you know it all simply because you can type? You don't. And your comment, "Is it very different to learning to be a detective?" is just further proof. A detective is a completely different job with a completely different set of objectives and pertinent laws. It's as different from being a journalist as being a fisherman. And, "they don't let the facts get in the way of the story they already have in mind to write. Now that's worth a degree" is just silly. Seriously. I don't think you've ever met an actual journalist and you obviously have no idea what they even do. You think they are detectives that can learn it all in a month? You are talking like a child.

red rag to red bull

Funny you try to equate speed to red bull then quickly say you can't stand energy drinks! Me too, tried red bull once and half a can gave me palpitations so threw it away. Like you, I drink espressos but can't stomach caffeine tablets like proplus. There was an experiment done some years ago where they fed spiders different drugs to see what would happen to their web-weaving skills. Caffeine did speed them up but the net was a nasty looking tangled mess! The speed one looked great! Sorry to hear about your bad trip. At uni we all learnt as much as we could about what we taking. A few accidents but no fatalities as I recall. Join Xomba Here

Good points Rycharde

Of course these are just my opinions and I do not profess to have a high knowledge in government, politics or pharmasuticals. In respect to illegal versus legal drugs, once a drug becomes legal it is suppose to be monitored or components watched. If an illegal drug becomes legal, the effects may become watered down and the tax revenue would actually decline because people would prefer the "real" thing. The drug speed is illegal, however you can get the same effect with legal drugs such as Ginseng, Monster drinks, Red Bull or other such "energy" drinks. I suspect the legalization versus non-legal has to do with the chemistry or components of the drug. For example, I am a coffee drinker but do not like the affects of energy drinks. The shakiness and the jumpiness are uncomfortable to me. (They also remind me of the days when I did use speed and ended up in the ER because of uncontrollable vomitting, lack of sleep and difficulty breathing. What a lesson!) MJ - Sending happy thoughts and Smiles! Avatar: Betrayal and Retribution http://www.valkyrieart.com/Poser1.html

Given how toxic so many

Given how toxic so many legal licensed drugs are, I suspect what is illegal is just another control mechanism. The pharmacos are perfectly happy to create zombies addicted to their pills so suspect that's also a red herring. Yes, some drugs are more addictive and damaging than others. So what? Is humanity still so infantile? There are quite a few "recreational" drugs I'd quite like to be able just to buy over the counter - MJ isn't one of them. For example, why is speed illegal and yet caffeine is everywhere? Join Xomba Here

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member