7
votes

Who Won The Olympics - The United States or China?

posted August 24, 2008 - 3:16pm
Who Won The Olympics - The United States or China?

The 2008 Beijing Olympic Games is over. Only the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games Closing Ceremony is left. So that leads to the question of which country won the Olympic Games this year. Would that be the United States with the most medals won? The United States won 110 medals. China won 100 medals. Or would that be China as China won the most gold medals? China won 51 gold medals whereas the United States won only 36 gold medals. I would say that the United States won. Wouldn't you want to count the most number of medals won instead of just who won the most gold medals?


Website: http://www.iht.com/articles/2008/08/24/sports/OLYR...


Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Since no one seems to be willing to read and learn..

Here are the words directly from the Olympic Charter "The Olympic Games are competitions between athletes in individual or team events and not between countries." You notice that the word competitions is plural. It is a series of competitions. WHO WON THE OLYMPICS

Xombytes

Yes

In any competition, peaceful or otherwise, there is always a winner and a loser. That's just the way it is. And yes, the opening ceremony was absolutely awesome. Nobody will ever be able to top that.

Make a lot of money writing on Xomba. Join Xomba here. View My Profile.

firework - not fake

the firework scene was not fake, just a portion of the telecast was digitalised since it would apparently have been dangerous for cameras to track the real firework footprints. So those who saw it in beijing saw it live and real My writings here My profile here

i agree

I fully agree when you say "this argument is not in any way in the Olympic spirit" and "the Olympics is designed to promote peace and cooperation between the countries of the world even when they may have conflicts off the Olympic field" However in the end there is a winner and a loser and ranks are presented every Olympics (less important than the main reason why we have the Olympics), and when a country claims they have won the olympics when they didn't, that is something we can disagree with especially when your from China. (i am not chinese btw) To sum up, I'm shocked the way how the opening ceremony was given such negative comments repeatedly and nothing good was mentioned, even if one of the firework scene was a fakery or not, overall that was the best olympic opening ceremoney with out a doubt. I'm also disappointed the fact that the US can't take coming 2nd behind China, and have to claim they have won the olympics. It's sad theres such an argument but the truth is still the truth.

Bow down to the MIghty "Americans".

"For the commentors from other countries who are trying to incite the U.S. commentors..." "To the people from India - let me know when you get to five total medals. (And no, you can't combine the last three Olympics to get that total.)" In other words.... OH, You Mere Mortals of lesser known lands, How dare you speaketh Thus to the Mighty Americans? Bow down to the God of all Gods. WE ARE THE TRUE CHAMPIONS!

Bow down to the MIghty "Americans".

"For the commentors from other countries who are trying to incite the U.S. commentors..." "To the people from India - let me know when you get to five total medals. (And no, you can't combine the last three Olympics to get that total.)" In other words.... OH, You Mere Mortals of lesser known lands, How dare you speaketh Thus to the Mighty Americans? Bow down to the God of all Gods. WE ARE THE TRUE CHAMPIONS!

Bow down to the MIghty "Americans".

"For the commentors from other countries who are trying to incite the U.S. commentors..." "To the people from India - let me know when you get to five total medals. (And no, you can't combine the last three Olympics to get that total.)" In other words.... OH, You Mere Mortals of lesser known lands, How dare you speaketh Thus to the Mighty Americans? Bow down to the God of all Gods. WE ARE THE TRUE CHAMPIONS!

Ridiculous Argument

This argument is not in any way in the Olympic spirit! How many people arguing about this have ever seriously competed in a sport? If you have competed and won (and lost), at some level, you might see the Olympics differently. The Olympics is designed to promote peace and cooperation between the countries of the world even when they may have conflicts off the Olympic field. It IS NOT a substitute for war. Did you see any representative of a National Olympic Committee receiving recognition as the winning country? Of course countries like the USA, China and Russia can field huge teams and will always win the lions share of the medals whether they are gold, silver or bronze but it should never become all about the biggest teams. Does that detract from the accomplishment of some of the smaller teams like Thailand for example, who came away from the games with two gold and two silver? Falling back on some of the logic used in these arguments, the top 8 in each event are recognized by an Oympic Certificate, so maybe we should add all of those up too? Maybe we should divide the number of medals by the number of athletes each country had competing in the games. (Actually, that might be a better measure of who was really the "winner" of the games.) As an American, of course I root for the home team, but I also cheer for the Kenyan who won his country's first gold in the Marathon. I saw the arguments starting, so I did post a byte linking to the Olympic Charter just in case anyone was interested in learning more about the Olympics and what they are all about.

Xombytes

""The "medal count" has

""The "medal count" has always been based on the total number of medals. China finished with ten less medals than the United States. If we are going to place China ahead of the U.S. then we need to put Japan (with 25 medals) ahead of France (with 40); we need to put Mexico (3) ahead of Turkey (8); we need to place Tunisia (1) ahead of Armenia (6); and we need to put 16 countries ahead of Cuba because only 2 of Cuba's 24 medals were gold. "" not if we use some point system like i mentioned above. if country X won 1-gold 3silver 13-bronze and country Y won 8-gold 6 silver 0-bronze.... ...country X would have a total of 17 medals and country Y would have a total of 14 medals it would look stupid if country X beats country Y due to "more medals" because gold, silver and bronze has different values, if they didn't why not just have one coloured medal and have three winners in each game.... therefore we should have a point system, since there are 3 different types of medals we should have something (like i mentioned above)like 3 points for gold, 2 points for silver and 1 point for bronze, just like they do for some leagues such as the English Premier League, 3 points for a Win 2 points for a Draw and 1 point for a Lost. PS. if you look at the official medal standings Japan is ahead of France, Mexico is ahead of Turkey and Tunisia is ahead of Armenia. Check it out yourself http://results.beijing2008.cn/WRM/ENG/INF/GL/95A/GL0000000.shtml

@Mr. Adhominem, it's all the Republican's and Israel's fault :)

To read my posts and articles click here: http://www.xomba.com/xombyte/lmorovan

To read my posts and articles click here:

http://www.xomba.com/xombyte/lmorovan

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can use BBCode tags in the text. URLs will automatically be converted to links.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <b> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <span> <object> <param> <embed> <table> <tr> <td> <div>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Join Xomba Today

Do you like to write? Would you like to make a little extra money on the side? These people do. Join the Xomba community today.
Become a Member